SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.77 número2Empowering and disempowering students in student-supervisor relationshipsDeveloping a scientific culture through supervision índice de autoresíndice de assuntospesquisa de artigos
Home Pagelista alfabética de periódicos  

Serviços Personalizados

Artigo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • Em processo de indexaçãoCitado por Google
  • Em processo de indexaçãoSimilares em Google

Compartilhar


Koers

versão On-line ISSN 0023-270X

Koers (Online) vol.77 no.2 Pretoria  2012

 

ORIGINAL RESEARCH

 

Human reproductive cloning and biotechnology: Rational, ethical and public concerns

 

Menslike voortplantingskloning en biotegnologie: Rasionele, etiese en publieke besorgdhede

 

 

M.E.S. (Elbie) van den Berg

Department of Philosophy, Practical & Systematic Theology, University of South Africa, South Africa

Correspondence

 

 


ABSTRACT

Previous research indicates a lack of clear international guidelines on the permissibility of embryonic stem cell research and human reproductive cloning. These studies suggest that this is the result of severe criticism from uninformed publics, whose arguments are based on misconceptions influenced by popular literature and science fiction films. However, the current research argues that public cloning attitudes that are based on real social and ethical concerns should be deployed to direct social and legal policy-making on human reproductive cloning. Addressing public concerns about human reproductive cloning is essential in exploring sound avenues for sensible biotechnology and policy-making. The research, on which this article reported, intended to give a critical evaluation of some major arguments for and against human reproductive cloning in order to establish whether or not these arguments hold up well under rational interrogation. Notwithstanding the author's critical attitude to uninformed opinions, false assumptions and unsound conclusions about the complex issue of human reproductive cloning, the author argued from the perspective that every life phenomenon is inextricably intertwined with everything else, and part of larger complex webs of interactions. Such a perspective recognised that the well-being of other human beings, including future human clones, is not only an existential, social and moral imperative but also epistemological. Against the backdrop of this perspective, critical questions arose that justified the creation of human clones in the face of possible defects and abnormalities in cloned children, as well as the possible harm to societies.


OPSOMMING

Vroeëre navorsing oor kloning wys op 'n afwesigheid van duidelike internasionale riglyne oor die aanvaarbaarheid van embrioniese stamsel-navorsing en menslike voortplantingskloning. Hierdie studies wys daarop dat dit te wyte is aan erge kritiek van die oningeligte publiek, wie se argumente gebaseer is op wanopvattings wat beïnvloed word deur populêre literatuur en wetenskapsfiksie-films. In hierdie artikel word daar egter aangevoer dat die publiek se houding, indien dit in werklike sosiale en etiese oorwegings gefundeer is, in ag geneem moet word om rigting te gee aan sosiale en wetlike besluitneming oor menslike voortplantingskloning. Die inagneming van openbare kommer oor menslike voortplantingskloning is essensieel in die soeke na rasionele en wyse beleidsbepaling en biotegnologiese oorwegings. Die navorsing waaroor hierdie artikel verslag lewer, poog om 'n kritiese evaluering van sommige dominante argumente vir en teen menslike voortplantingskloning te gee in die lig van rasionele oorweging. Nieteenstaande die outeur se kritiese benadering tot oninligte opinies, vals aannames en ongegronde gevolgtrekkings oor die komplekse kwessie van menslike voortplantingskloning, argumenteer die outeur vanuit die perspektief dat elke lewensverskynsel onontkombaar verbonde is en deel vorm van 'n groter komplekse netwerk van interaksies. Hierdie perspektief erken dat die welsyn van ander mense, insluitende toekomstige menslike klone, nie slegs 'n eksistensiële, sosiale en etiese kwessie is nie, maar ook 'n epistemologiese imperatief. Teen die agtergrond van hierdie perspektief, opper die outeur kritiese vrae oor die regverdiging van die skepping van toekomstige menslike klone te midde van die moontlikheid van defekte en abnormaliteite in gekloonde kinders, asook moontlike sosiale skade.


 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

Acknowledgements

Competing interests

The author declares that she has no financial or personal relationships which may have inappropriately influenced her in writing this article.

 

References

Annas, G.J., 1998, 'Why we should ban human cloning', New England Journal of Medicine 339(1), 22-25.         [ Links ]

Bates, B.R., Lynch, J.A., Bevan, J.L. & Condit, C.M., 2005, 'Warranted concerns, warranted outlooks: a focus group study of public understandings of genetic research', Social Science & Medicine 60(4), 331-344.         [ Links ]

Bates, B.R., 2005, 'Public culture and public understanding of genetics: a focus group study', Public Understanding of Science 14(2), 47-65.         [ Links ]

Baird, P.A., 1999, 'Cloning of animals and humans: what should the policy response be?', Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 42(3), 179-194.         [ Links ]

Bouchard, T.J. (Jr), 1997, 'IQ similarities in twins reared apart: findings and responses to critics', in R.J. Sternberg & E.L. Grigorenko (eds.), Intelligence, heredity, and environment, pp. 126-160, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.         [ Links ]

Bruce, D., 1998, Should we clone humans?, viewed 26 December 2011, http://www.srtp.org.uk/clonhum2.html.         [ Links ]

Cole-Turner, R. (ed.), 2001, Beyond cloning: Religion and the remaking of humanity, Trinity Press International, Harrisburg.         [ Links ]

Davis, D., 2009, Genetic dilemmas: Reproductive technology, parental choice, and children's futures, 2nd edn., Oxford University Press, New York.         [ Links ]

Dawkins, R., 1998, 'What's wrong with cloning?', in M.C. Nussbaum & C.R. Sunstein (eds.), Clones and clones: Facts and fantasies about human cloning, pp. 54-66, Norton, New York.         [ Links ]

Du Plessis, P.G.W., 2006, 'Wetenskap met en sonder diepte?', Koers 71(1), 43-71.         [ Links ]

Eley, T.C., Gregory, A.M., Clark, D.M. & Ehlers, A., 2007, 'Feeling anxious: A twin study of panic/somatic ratings, anxiety sensitivity and heartbeat perception in children', Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 48(12), 1184-1191.         [ Links ]

Espejo, R., 2002, Human embryo experimentation, Greenhaven Press, Michigan.         [ Links ]

Evans, J.H., 2002, Playing God?, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.         [ Links ]

Feinberg, J.S. & Feinberg, P.D., 2010, Ethics for a brave new world, 2nd edn., Crossway, Illinois.         [ Links ]

Fukuyama, F., 2002, Our posthuman future. Consequences of the biotechnology revolution, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York.         [ Links ]

Gaskell, G., Allum, N. & Stares, S., 2003, Europeans and biotechnology in 2002: Eurobarometer 58.0, European Commission, Brussels.         [ Links ]

Gosden, R., 1999, Designer babies: The brave new world of reproductive technology, Victor Gollancz, London.         [ Links ]

Green, R.M., 2001, The human embryo research debates: Bioethics in the vortex of controversy Oxford University Press, New York.         [ Links ]

Harris, J., 2004, On cloning, Routledge, London.         [ Links ]

Holm, S., 1998, 'A life in the shadow: one reason why we should not clone humans', Cambridge Quarterly of Health and Ethics 7(3), 160-162.         [ Links ]

Ishiguro, K., 2005, Never let me go, Faber & Faber, London.         [ Links ]

Jaenisch, R. & Wilmut, I., 2001, 'Don't clone humans', Science 291(12), 2551-2554.         [ Links ]

Johnson, G., 1997, 'Don't worry: They still can't clone a brain', New York Times, 02 March, p. 13.         [ Links ]

Kass, L.R., 1997, 'Wisdom of repugnance', The New Republic, 02 June, pp. 17-26.         [ Links ]

Kass, L.R., 2002, Human cloning and human dignity, Public Affairs, New York.         [ Links ]

Kitcher, P., 2000, 'There will never be another you', in B. MacKinnon (ed.), Human cloning. Science, ethics, and public policy, pp. 53-67, University of Illinois Press, Urbana and Chicago.         [ Links ]

Kluger, J., 1997, 'Will we follow the sheep?', Time, 10 March, pp. 70-72.         [ Links ]

Lewontin, R.C., 2000, 'Cloning and the fallacy of biological determinism', in B. MacKinnon (ed.), Human cloning. Science, ethics, and public policy, pp. 37-49, University of Illinois Press, Urbana/Chicago.         [ Links ]

Macintosch, K.L., 2005, Illegal beings. Human clones and the law, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.         [ Links ]

MacKinnon, B. (ed.), 2000, Human cloning. Science, ethics, and public policy, University of Illinois Press, Urbana/Chicago.         [ Links ]

Maienschein, J., 2005, Whose view of life? Embryos, cloning and stem cells, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.         [ Links ]

Maturana, H. & Varela, F., 1987, The tree of knowledge: The biological roots of human understanding, Shambhala, Boston.         [ Links ]

McKibben, B., 2003, Enough: Staying human in an engineered age, Holt and Co., New York.         [ Links ]

Morris, S.H. & Adley, C.C., 2001, 'Irish public perceptions and attitudes to modern biotechnology', Trends in Biotechnology 19(1), 43-48.         [ Links ]

Murray, T.H., 2001, 'Even if it worked, cloning wouldn't bring her back', Washington Post, 08 April, n.p.         [ Links ]

National Bioethics Advisory Commission (NBAC), 1997, Cloning human beings, Maryland, Rockville.         [ Links ]

Nisbet, M.C., 2004, 'Public opinion about stem cell research and human cloning', Public Opinion Quarterly 8(1), 131-154.         [ Links ]

Paris, P.J., 2001, 'A view from the underside', in R. Cole-Turner (ed.), Beyond cloning: Religion and the remaking of humanity, pp. 66-74, Trinity Press International, Harrisburg.         [ Links ]

Pence, G.E., 1998a, Who's afraid of human cloning?, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, New York.         [ Links ]

Pence, G.E. (ed.), 1998b, Flesh of my flesh: The ethics of cloning humans: A reader, Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham.         [ Links ]

Pollack, R., 1993, 'Beyond cloning', New York Times, 17 November.         [ Links ]

Potton, C.S. (ed.), 1997, Stem cells, Academic Press, London.         [ Links ]

Priest, S.H., 2000, 'US public opinion divided over biotechnology?', Nature Biotechnology 18(11), 939-942.         [ Links ]

Savulescu, J. & Bostrom, N., 2009, Human enhancement, Oxford University Press, New York.         [ Links ]

Seidel, G.E. (Jr), 2000, 'Cloning mammals: Methods, applications, and characteristics of cloned animals', in B. MacKinnon (ed.), Human cloning. Science, ethics, and public policy, pp. 17-36, University of Illinois Press, Urbana/Chicago.         [ Links ]

Shepherd, R., Barnett, J., Cooper, H., Coyle, A., Moran-Ellis, J., Senior, V. et al., 2006, 'Understanding the complexity of British public attitudes towards human cloning', Social Science and Medicine 61(4), 321-339.         [ Links ]

Silver, L.M., 1998, 'Cloning, ethics, and religion', Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 7(2), 168-172.         [ Links ]

Steinbock, B., 2011, Life before birth. The moral and legal status of embryos and fetuses, Oxford University Press, New York.         [ Links ]

Stock, G., 2003, Redesigning humans: our inevitable genetic future, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston.         [ Links ]

Strong, C., 2005a, 'The ethics of reproductive cloning', Ethics, Science and Moral Philosophy of Assisted Human Reproduction 10(1), 45-49.         [ Links ]

Strong, C., 2005b, 'Reproductive cloning combined with genetic modification', Journal of Medical Ethics 31(3), 654-658.         [ Links ]

Thomson, J., Itskovitz-Eldor, J., Shapiro, S.S., Waknitz, M.A., Swiergiel, J.J., Marshall, V.S. et al., 1998, 'Embryonic stem cell lines derived from human blastocysts', Science 282(9), 1145-1147.         [ Links ]

Van Niekerk, A. & Van Zyl, L., 1996, 'Embryo experimentation, personhood and human rights', South African Journal of Philosophy 15(4), 139-149.         [ Links ]

Varela, F., Thompson, E. & Rosch, E., 1991, The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience, MIT Press, Cambridge.         [ Links ]

Vogelstein, B., Alberts, B. & Shine, K., 2002,' Letter to the editor', Science 297(1), 52-53.         [ Links ]

West, M., 2003, The immortal cell: How stem cell biotechnology can conquer cancer and extend life, Doubleday, New York.         [ Links ]

Williamson, R., 1999,' Human reproductive cloning is unethical because it undermines autonomy: commentary on Savulescu', Journal of Medical Ethics 25(2), 96-97.         [ Links ]

Wilmut, I., Schnieke, A.E., McWhir, J., Kind, A.J. & Campbell, K.H.S., 1997, 'Viable offspring derived from fetal and adult mammalian cells', Nature 385(3), 810-813.         [ Links ]

 

 

Correspondence:
Elbie van den Berg
PO Box 392
Pretoria 0003
South Africa
Email: vdberms@unisa.ac.za

Received: 02 Mar. 2012
Accepted: 03 Sept. 2012
Published: 14 Dec. 2012

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License