SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.76 issue1The return of religionGod is: Children's Bibles and Bible storybooks' presentation of religious values author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Koers

On-line version ISSN 0023-270X

Koers (Online) vol.76 n.1 Pretoria  2011

 

RESEARCH ARTICLE

 

Towards a theory of presuppositions: Kuyperian contributions

 

'n Teorie van vooronderstellings: Kuyperiaanse bydraes

 

 

R. Coletto

School of Philosophy, Potchefstroom Campus, North-West University, Potchefstroom. E-mail: renato.coletto@nwu.ac.za

 

 


ABSTRACT

One of the most important themes of contemporary philosophy of science was the discovery of presuppositional beliefs and frameworks as factors influencing scientific research. This article explores the development of a theory of presuppositions within Kuyperian philosophy. The authors discussed in this study represent a few Kuyperian families: Dooyeweerd, Vollenhoven (briefly), Wolterstorff, Klapwijk, Duvenage and Botha. The perspective is both historical and systematic. Historically, it refers to the main authors who contributed to establishing the basic features of such a theory. Systematically, the article tries to evaluate the proposals of each contributor by assessing their value and limits. In doing so, the author often defends his own preferences and indicates the directions to be followed.

Key-concepts: Christian scholarship, Kuyperian tradition, presupopsitional frameworks, presuppositions, prescientific, theorising, scientific


OPSOMMING

Een van die belangrikste temas van die huidige wetenskapsfilosofie is die ontdekking van vooronderstellings, aannames en raamwerke as faktore wat wetenskaplike navorsing kan beïnvloed. Hierdie artikel verken die ontwikkeling van 'n teorie van vooronderstellings binne die Kuyperiaanse filosofie. Die outeurs wat in hierdie studie bespreek word, verteenwoordig enkele Kuyperiaanse families: Dooyeweerd, Vollenhoven (kortliks), Wolterstorff, Klapwijk, Duvenage en Botha. Die perspektief is sowel histories as sistematies. Histories word na die belang-rikste outeurs verwys wat 'n bydrae gelewer het om die basiese kenmerke van so 'n teorie te vestig. Sistematies probeer die artikel om die voorstelle van elke bydraer te evalueer deur hulle waarde en grense te meet. In die proses verdedig die outeur in baie gevalle sy eie voorkeure en dui die rigting aan wat gevolg behoort te word.

Kernbegrippe: Christelike wetenskap, Kuyperiaanse tradisie, vooronderstellings, voorwetenskaplike, vooronderstellingsraamwerke, teoretisering, wetenskaplike


 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

 

List of references

BOTHA, M.E. 1993. The mediating role of metaphor and analogy in the relationship between science and religion. Tydskrif vir Christelike wetenskap, 29(3):36-50.         [ Links ]

BOTHA, M.E. 1996. Science, myth and metaphor. (In Blomberg, D., ed. Human being: essays dedicated to Stuart Fowler. Melbourne: Association for Christian Scholarship. p. 39-67.         [ Links ])

BOTHA, M.E. 2002. Of light and limits: philosophy matters. Koers, 36(2):207-225.         [ Links ]

BOTHA, M.E. 2006. Metaphor, embodiment and fiduciary beliefs in science. Tydskrif vir Christelike wetenskap, 42(Spesiale uitgawe 1):17-36.         [ Links ]

BOTHA, M.E. 2007. Metaphor and its moorings: studies in the grounding of metaphorical meaning. Bern: Peter Lang.         [ Links ]

CLOUSER, R.A. 1991. The myth of religious neutrality: an essay on the hidden role of religious belief in theories. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.         [ Links ]

COLETTO, R. 2007. Presuppositions and the challenge to objectivity in late-modern philosophy of science: causes and possible remedies. Koers, 72(4):583-602.         [ Links ]

COLETTO, R. 2009. Wolterstorff's critique of the reformational view of scholarship in his essay On Christian learning. Koers, 74(3):387-407.         [ Links ]

COLETTO, R. 2010a. Interaction and antithesis in reformational scholarship. Acta academica, 42(1):1-25.         [ Links ]

COLETTO, R. 2010b. The role of the Bible in reformational philosophy: historical and systematic notes. In die Skriflig, 44(3 & 4):545-564.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1959. Cinq conferences. La revue réformée, 10(3):3-76.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1966. Het oecumenisch-reformatorisch grondmotief van de wijsbegeerte der wetsidee en de grondslag van de Vrije Universiteit. Philosophia reformata, 31(1 & 2):3-15.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1980. In the twilight of western thought. Nutley: Craig.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1984. A new critique of theoretical thought. 4 vols. Jordan Station: Paideia.         [ Links ]

DUVENAGE, B. 1985. Christian scholarship as Word-bound scholarship. Potchefstroom: Potchefstroom Studies in Christian Scholarship.         [ Links ]

FRAME, J.M. 1987. The doctrine of the knowledge of God. Phillipsburg: Presbyterian and Reformed Publication Company.         [ Links ]

GEERTSEMA, H.G. 1987. Christian philosophy: transformation or inner reformation? Philosophia reformata, 52(2):139-165.         [ Links ]

HART, H. 1983. The articulation of belief: a link between rationality and commitment. (In Hart, H., Van der Hoeven, J. & Wolterstorff, N.P., eds. Rationality in the Calvinian tradition. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 209-248.         [ Links ])

HART, H. 1985. Dooyeweerd's Gegenstand theory of theory. (In McIntire, C.T., ed. The legacy of Herman Dooyeweerd. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 143-166.         [ Links ])

HART, H. 1988. The idea of an inner reformation of the sciences. (In Marshall, P.A. & Vander Vennen, R., eds. Social sciences in Christian perspective. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 13-31.         [ Links ])

KLAPWIJK, J. 1984. Religieuse antithese en teoretishe communicatie in de sociale wetenschappe. Radix, 10(1):153-168.         [ Links ]

KLAPWIJK, J. 1986. Antithesis, synthesis and the idea of transformational philosophy. Philosophia reformata, 51(1-2):138-152.         [ Links ]

KLAPWIJK, J. 1987. Reformational philosophy on the boundary between the past and the future. Philosophia reformata, 52(2):101-134.         [ Links ]

KLAPWIJK, J. 2008. Purpose in the living world? Creation and emergent evolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.         [ Links ]

KOK, J.A. 1988. Vollenhoven and scriptural philosophy. Philosophia reformata, 53(2):101-142.         [ Links ]

OLTHUIS, J.H. 1989. On worldviews. (In Marshall, P.A., Griffioen, S., & Mouw, R.J., eds. Stained glass: worldviews and social science. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 41-55.         [ Links ])

POLANYI, M. 1946. Science faith and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.         [ Links ]

STAFLEU, M.D. 1987. Theories at work: on the structure and functioning of theories in science, in particular during the Copernican revolution. Lanham: University Press of America.         [ Links ]

STRAUSS, D.F.M. 2009. Philosophy: the discipline of the disciplines. Grand Rapids: Paideia Reformational Project.         [ Links ]

VAN DER WALT, B.J. 2008. The eye is the lamp of the body: worldviews and their impact. Potchefstroom: The Institute for Contemporary Christianity in Africa.         [ Links ]

VAN RIESSEN, H. 1973. Science between presuppositions and decisions. Philosophia reformata, 38(1): 114-126.         [ Links ]

VANDER STELT, J.C. 1990. Philosophical assumptions in North-American presbyterian theology. Pro Rege, 18(4):9-19.         [ Links ]

VENTER, J.J. 1994. Reformational university basis in operation. Orientation, (71-74):260-294.         [ Links ]

VOLLENHOVEN, D.H. Th. 1953. Schriftgebruik en wijsbegeerte. Mededeelingen van de Vereeniging voor Calvinistische Wijsbegeerte, Sept. 6-9.         [ Links ]

VOLLENHOVEN, D.H. Th. 1992. Schriftgebruik en wijsbegeerte. (In Tol, A., Bril, K.A., eds. Vollenhoven als wijsgeer: inleidingen en teksten. Amsterdam: Buijten & Schipperhijn. p. 97-106.         [ Links ])

WOLTERS, A.M. 1989. On the idea of worldview and its relation to philosophy. (In Marshall, P.A., Griffioen, S. & Mouw, R.J., eds. Stained glass: worldviews and social science. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 14-25.         [ Links ])

WOLTERSTORFF, N.P. 1976. Reason within the bounds of religion. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

WOLTERSTORFF, N.P. 1980. Educating for responsible action. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

WOLTERSTORFF, N.P. 1989. On Christian learning. (In Marshall, P.A., Griffioen, S. & Mouw, R.J., eds. Stained glass: worldviews and social science. Lanham: University Press of America. p. 56-80.         [ Links ])

WOLTERSTORFF, N.P. 2004. Educating for shalom: essays on Christian higher education. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

WYKSTRA, S.J. s.a. Religious beliefs and metaphysical beliefs: the distinction and its importance for understanding past and present science. Grand Rapids: Calvin College.         [ Links ]

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License