SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.76 número1Education for women: A consideration of the philosophical issues in dialogue with Martha NussbaumTowards a theory of presuppositions: Kuyperian contributions índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados

Articulo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • En proceso de indezaciónCitado por Google
  • En proceso de indezaciónSimilares en Google

Compartir


Koers

versión On-line ISSN 0023-270X

Koers (Online) vol.76 no.1 Pretoria  2011

 

RESEARCH ARTICLE

 

The return of religion

 

Die terugkeer van religie

 

 

S. Griffioen

Rijksstraatweg 77, 3632AA Loenen aan de Vecht, Nederland. E-mail: griffioen.sander@gmail.com

 

 


ABSTRACT

Religion is back in Philosophy as a respectable subject. Part 1 first charts what MacIntyre, Taylor and Derrida have meant in this regard. Subsequently, it turns to the Enlightenment to determine what constituted the breakthrough. It is found that even where the Enlightenment gave maximum room to religion (i.e. as a civic religion and as "religion of the heart") it still excluded a constitutive relation to a transcendent revelation.
Part 2 centres on the religion-faith distinction in reformational philosophy. Similar to the Enlightenment, religion is understood as part of human nature. However, human nature itself is conceived as intrinsically religious and depending for its light on revelation. Secondly, "religion" in this context also encompasses idols and religious substitutes. Thus, it directs attention to shopping malls, football stadiums, health policy, et cetera, as possible contexts of a return of religion. Examples show that this has become a popular approach. However, most of the publications surveyed fail to distinguish between an "analogical" and a "pistically qualified" use of religion, and are open to exaggerations (the shopping mall and football stadiums as temples, etc.). At this junction, the relevance is shown of the religion-faith distinction as well as of Elaine Botha's theory of metaphors. The epilogue offers an integration of parts one and two.

Key concepts: Enlightenment, faith, idol, religion, worldview


OPSOMMING

Religie is terug in die Filosofie as 'n waardige onderwerp. In Deel 1 word eerstens uitgestip wat MacIntyre, Taylor en Derrida in hierdie verband bedoel. Daarna word na die Verligting gekyk om te bepaal wat die deurbraak moontlik gemaak het. Die bevinding is dat, selfs waar die Verligting heeltemal plek gemaak het vir religie (as 'n siviele religie en as religie van die hart), dit steeds 'n wesenlike verband met 'n transendentele openbaring uitgesluit het.
Deel 2 sentreer rondom die religie-geloofsonderskeid in reformatoriese filosofie. Ooreenkomstig met die Verligting, word religie as deel van die menslike natuur verstaan. Menslike natuur word egter op sigself verstaan as wesenlik religieus en afhanklik van openbaring vir sy lig. Tweedens omvat "religie" in hierdie konteks ook afgode en religieuse plaasvervangers. Dit vestig dus die aandag op winkelarkades, voetbalstadions, gesondheidsbeleid, ensovoorts as moontlike kontekste van 'n terugkeer van religie. Uit voorbeelde kan gesien word dat hierdie 'n populêre benadering geword het. Die meeste van die publikasies wat ondersoek is, versuim egter om tussen 'n "analogiese" en 'n "pisties-gekwalifiseerde" gebruik van religie te onderskei en is oop vir oordrywing (bv. die winkelarkade en voetbalstadions as tempels). By hierdie kruispunt word op die relevansie van die religie-geloofsonderskeid gewys, sowel as op Elaine Botha se metafoorteorie. Die epiloog bied 'n integrasie van dele een en twee.

Kernbegrippe: afgod, geloof, religie, Verligting, wêreldbeskouing


 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

 

List of references

BERGER, P. 1979. The heretical imperative. New York: Anchor.         [ Links ]

BOTHA, M.E. 2007. Metaphor and its moorings. Bern: Lang.         [ Links ]

DERRIDA, J. 1999. Donner la mort. Paris: Galilée.         [ Links ]

DESMOND, W. 2005. Is there a sabbath for thought? Between religion and philosophy. New York: Fordham.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1953. A new critique of theoretical thought. Vol. 1. Amsterdam: Presbyterian & Reformed Publishing Company.         [ Links ]

DOOYEWEERD, H. 1979. Roots of western culture. Toronto: Wedge.         [ Links ]

DOSTOEVSKY, F. 2002. The great inquisitor of Sevilla. (In Dostoevsky, F. The brothers Karamazov. Part 2, Book 5, ch. 5: II-5. Trans. by Richaard Pevear & Larissa Volokhonsky. New York: Farrar, Strauss & Giroux.         [ Links ])

GRIFFIOEN, S. 2010. Towards a philosophy of God: a study in William Desmond's thought. Philosophia reformata, 75:117-140.         [ Links ]

HEGEL, G.W.F. 1966. Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Religion. Vol. 2. Hamburg: Meiner.         [ Links ]

HEGEL, G.W.F. 1980. Phánomenologie des Geistes: gesammelte Werke. Vol. 9. Hamburg: Meiner.         [ Links ]

HEGEL, G.W.F. 1987. Vorlesungsmanuskripte 1 (1816-1831). Hamburg: Meiner. (Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 17)        [ Links ]

HEYNS, M. 2002. The transformation of the concept of "Self": with specific reference to the work of Charles Taylor. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit. (Dissertation.         [ Links ])

ISRAEL, J. 2007. Freedom of thought versus freedom of religion. Public lecture, Nov. 11, 2006. Amsterdam: De Rode Hoed.         [ Links ]

KUYPER, A. 2000. Lectures on Calvinism: the Stone Lectures of 1898. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

LEMMENS, W. 1999. After virtue: a study in moral theory of Alasdair MacIntyre. (In Boey, K., Cools, A., Leilich, J. & Oger, E., ed. Ex libris van de filosofie in de 20e eeuw. Vol. 2. Leuven: Acco. p. 349-372.         [ Links ])

MACINTYRE, A. 1981. After virtue. London: Duckworth.         [ Links ]

MACINTYRE, A. 1988, Whose justice? Which rationality? Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.         [ Links ]

OLTHUIS. J. 1985. Dooyeweerd on religion and faith. (In Mcintire, C.T., ed. The legacy of Herman Dooyeweerd. Lanham: University of America Press. p. 21-40.         [ Links ])

PATOCKA, J. 1990. Essais hérétiques sur la philosophie de l'histoire. Trans. by Erika Abrams. Paris: Verdier.         [ Links ]

POLINDER, D. 2010. In due course - or in the hereafter? Dr. W. Aalders' view of history compared with that of Dr. H. Dooyeweerd. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit. (M.Phil. thesis.         [ Links ])

RICKERT, H. 1926. Max Weber und seine Stellung zur Wissenschaft. Logos, 15:222-237.         [ Links ]

SCHUURMAN, E. 1995. The technological culture between the times. (In Griffioen, S. & Balk, B., ed. Christian philosophy at the close of the twentieth century. Kampen: Kok. p. 185-200.         [ Links ])

SCHUURMAN, E. 2002. Bevrijding van het technische wereldbeeld. Delft: Delft Technische Universiteit.         [ Links ]

SIBLEY, L.C. 2010. Review of Smith, J.K.A.: desiring the kingdom. Pro Rege, 38(4):32-33.         [ Links ]

SMITH, J.K.A. 2009. Desiring the kingdom: worship, worldview, and cultural formation. Grand Rapids: Baker.         [ Links ]

TAYLOR, C. 1975. Hegel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.         [ Links ]

TAYLOR, C. 1989. Sources of the self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.         [ Links ]

TAYLOR, C. 2007. A secular age. Harvard: Belknap.         [ Links ]

VERHOOGT, J. 1989. Sociology and progress. (In Marshall, P.A., Griffioen, S. & Mouw, R.J., ed. Stained glass. Lanham: University of Amsterdam Press. p. 119-139.         [ Links ])

VERKERK, M. 2010. Herordening van het sacrale: religie, ethiek en zorginnovatie. Maastricht: University of Maastricht Press.         [ Links ]

VOLLENHOVEN, D.H. Th. 2005. Isagôgè Philosophiae: introduction to philosophy. Trans by J.H. Kok & ed. by A. Tol. Sioux Center: Dordt College Press.         [ Links ]

WINOCK, M. 2010. Madame de Staël. Paris: Fayard.         [ Links ]

WRIGHT, N.T. 2000. The challenge of Jesus. London: SPCK.         [ Links ]

ZUIDEMA, S.U. 1957. Communisme in ontbinding. Wageningen: Zomer & Keuning.         [ Links ]

 

 

1 I gratefully acknowledge the help of Jonathan Tipping (Groningen) in checking my English.

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License