SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.75 issue3Cultural pathways and pitfalls in South Africa: A reflection on moral agency and leadership from a Christian perspectiveDialogical inquiry as an instrument of the reconciliation of conflict in the hands of Christian leaders author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Koers

On-line version ISSN 0023-270X

Koers (Online) vol.75 n.3 Pretoria  2010

 

Female leaders in an international evangelical mission organisation: An empirical study of Youth With A Mission in Germany

 

Vroulike leiers in 'n internasionale evangeliese sendingorganisasie: 'n Empiriese ondersoek in Youth With A Mission in Duitsland

 

 

F.A.S. Hornstra-Fuchs ; W.L. Hornstra

Department of Philosophy and Systematic Theology, University of South Africa, PRETORIA and School of Biblical Studies, University of the Nations, HURLACH, Germany. E-mail: wilrensandfranziska@sbsgermany.de

 

 


ABSTRACT

Evangelicals are frequently perceived as conservative, for instance in their perspective on women. There is indeed a widespread evangelical hierarchical or complementarian theological view which objects to women in church leadership. There is, however, a growing egalitarian counter position, sometimes also referred to as "evangelical feminism", which supports female leadership.
This article concentrates on the international missionary organisation Youth With A Mission (YWAM), which clearly endorses female leaders in formal statements. In YWAM Germany, however, women are under-represented in leadership positions.
The article seeks to explain this under-representation, especially in terms of the role played by Scripture.
By means of interviews with leaders in YWAM Germany, possible answers were explored. Surprisingly, for an evangelical organisation, the interpretation of Scripture proved not to be a significant factor. Factors that do play a role are church background, the lack of female role models, lower self-confidence of women, family responsibilities, and the role of incumbent leadership. The latter appears to be the most crucial factor, since the incumbent leaders, who mostly are men, select and appoint new leaders. It is likely that in this they are influenced by stereotypical conceptions of the leader as male and are inclined to appoint leaders similar to themselves.

Key concepts: evangelicals women, under-representation in leadership positions, Youth With A Mission, Germany


OPSOMMING

Evangeliese Christene word dikwels gesien as konserwatief, byvoorbeeld met betrekking tot hulle perspektief op vroue in die bediening. Daar bestaan inderdaad 'n breed aanvaarde hiërargiese en komplimentêre evangeliese teologiese perspektief wat probleme het met vroue se leierskap in die kerk. Daar is egter ook 'n groeiende egalitêre teenposisie wat die leierskap van vroue ondersteun.
Hierdie artikel fokus op die internasionale sendingorganisasie Youth With A Mission (YWAM), wat die beginsel van vroue in leierskapsposisies duidelik in formele uitsprake ondersteun. In YWAM Duitsland is vroue onderverteenwoordig in leiersposisies. Hierdie artikel poog om hierdie onderverteenwoordiging te verduidelik, veral met betrekking tot die rol wat die Bybel speel.
Deur middel van onderhoude met leiers in YWAM Duitsland word na moontlike antwoorde gesoek. Verrassend genoeg blyk dit dat die interpretasie van die Bybel nie 'n deurslaggewende rol hierin speel nie. Faktore wat 'n rol speel is eerder kerklike agtergrond, 'n gebrek aan vroulike rolmodelle, minder selfvertroue by vroue, verantwoordelikhede in die gesin en die rol van bestaande leiers. Laasgenoemde blyk die mees deurslaggewende faktor te wees, omdat die leiers wat nuwe leiers selekteer en aanstel tans meestal mans is. Dit is waarskynlik dat hulle hierin beïnvloed word deur 'n stereotipiese beeld van leierskap en voorkeur gee aan manlike leiers.

Kernbegrippe: evangeliese Christene vroue, onderverteenwoordiging in leiersposisies, Youth With A Mission, Duitsland


 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

 

List of references

ANON. 2002. Youth With A Mission is planning Connexity 2002, the first international YWAM gathering on global women's issues. God's Word to women newsletter, 3(1), Summer. http://godswordtowomen.org/newsletter/newsletters/summer2002.htm Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

BROWN ZIKMUND, B., LUMMIS, A.T. & CHANG, P.M.Y. 1998. Clergy women: an uphill calling. Westminster: John Knox.         [ Links ]

CHEMERS, M.M. 1997. An integrative theory of leadership. Mahwah: Erlbaum.         [ Links ]

CHILDERS, P. & CHILDERS, S. 2006. A voice for the voiceless: 30 days of prayer for the voiceless. Hawaii: YWAM.         [ Links ]

CLARK KROEGER, R. & CLARK KROEGER, C. 1998. I suffer not a woman: rethinking 1 Timothy 2:11-15 in light of ancient evidence. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House.         [ Links ]

CONRAD, C. 1998. Der Dienst der ledigen Frau in deutschen Glaubensmissionen: Geschichte und Beurteilung. Bonn: Verlag für Kultur & Wissenschaft.         [ Links ]

CUNNINGHAM, L. 2000. A final word. (In Cunningham, L. & Hamilton, D.J., ed. Why not women? A biblical study of women in missions, ministry, and leadership. Seattle: YWAM. p. 235-239.         [ Links ])

CUNNINGHAM, L. & ROGERS, J. 1984. Is that really you, God? Hearing the voice of God. Seattle: YWAM.         [ Links ]

EULENHOEFER-MANN, B. 2003. Missionary work of single German women in China from 1886-1914: a comparison between missiological theory and praxis on the mission field. Pasadena: Fuller Theological Seminary. (Ph.D. thesis.         [ Links ])

GALLAGHER, S.K. 2004. The marginalization of evangelical feminism. Sociology of religion, 65(3):215-237.         [ Links ]

GEREFORMEERDE KERKE IN SUID-AFRIKA. 2009. Handelinge van die 50e nasionale sinode van die Gereformeerde Kerke in Suid-Afrika. Potchefstroom: GKSA.         [ Links ]

GKSA see GEREFORMEERDE KERKE IN SUID-AFRIKA        [ Links ]

GREEN, L. 2004. Perspective: the quest at the heart of YWAM. http://www.ywam.org/articles/article.asp?AID=215 Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

GUSHEE, D.P. 2008. The future of faith in American politics: the public witness of the evangelical center. Waco: Baylor University Press.         [ Links ]

HABERMANN-HORSTMEIER, L., ALBRECHT, K., BRAUN, B., GANTER, E. & THIERER, M. 2007. Karrierehindernisse für Frauen in Führungspositionen - Ergebnisse einer empirischen Studie an 300 Frauen aus dem deutschen Mittel- und Topmanagement. Villingen-Schwenningen: STZ Unternehmen & Führungskräfte.         [ Links ]

HORNSTRA-FUCHS, F.A.S. 2009. Women in Christian leadership: an empirical study of "Youth With A Mission", Germany. Pretoria: University of South Africa. (M.Th. dissertation.         [ Links ])

INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF WORLD EVANGELIZATION. 1974. The Lausanne Covenant. http://www.lausanne.org/covenant Date of access: 30 Mar. 2010.         [ Links ]

KRETZSCHMAR, L. 1995. Gender and oppression: a South African feminist underview. Missionalia, 23(2):147-161.         [ Links ]

MAYRING, P. 2007. Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse: Grundlagen und Techniken. Weinheim: Beltz.         [ Links ]

MCCLUNG, F. 2005. Authority: its use and abuse. (In University of the Nations. 2005 University of the Nations Reference Guide. Lausanne: University of the Nations. p. 159-166.         [ Links ])

MICKELSEN, A.M., ed. 1986. Women, authority and the Bible. Downers Grove: InterVarsity.         [ Links ]

MORETON, A.L. & NEWSOM, R.W. 2004a. Personal and academic backgrounds of female chief academic officers in evangelical Christian colleges and universities. Part 1. Christian higher education, 3(1):79-95.         [ Links ]

MORETON, A.L. & NEWSOM, R.W. 2004b. Female chief academic officers in evangelical Christian colleges and universities. Part 2: Reflections on careers, marriage, and faith. Christian higher education, 3(4):313-328.         [ Links ]

NEUBERGER, O. 2002. Führen und führen lassen: Ansätze, Ergebnisse und Kritik der Führungsforschung. 6. Aufl. Stuttgart: Lucius & Lucius.         [ Links ]

PIPER, J. & GRUDEM, W., eds. 1991. Recovering biblical manhood and womanhood: a response to evangelical feminism. Wheaton: Crossway Books.         [ Links ]

RICKENS, C. 2008. Geschlossene Gesellschaft! Managermagazin, (2):123-127.         [ Links ]

SAMUEL, V.K. & SUGDEN, C. 1999. Mission as transformation: a theology of the whole gospel. Oxford: Regnum Books.         [ Links ]

SCHEIN, V.E., MUELLER, R., LITUCHY, T. & LIU, J. 1996. Think manager - think male: a global phenomenon? Journal of organizational behavior, 17:33-41.         [ Links ]

SCHMALENBACH, H.-M. 2007. Frausein zur Ehre Gottes - im Kontext verschiedener Kulturen. Marburg: Francke.         [ Links ]

SCHNEIDER, B. 2007. Weibliche Führungskräfte - die Ausnahme im Management: eine empirische Untersuchung zur Unterrepräsentanz von Frauen im Management in Großunternehmen in Deutschland. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.         [ Links ]

SIDER, R.J. 1978. Rich Christians in an age of hunger: a biblical study. London: Hodder & Stoughton.         [ Links ]

SMITH, M.B., ed. 2000. Gender or giftedness: a challenge to rethink the basis for leadership in the Christian community - a study of the role of women. Manila: World Evangelical Fellowship Commission on Women's Concerns.         [ Links ]

SMITH, M.B. & KERN, I., eds. 2000. Ohne Unterschied? Frauen und Männer im Dienst für Gott: Leitungsaufgaben in christlichen Gemeinden und Werken - eine Herausforderung, die Grundlagen neu zu überdenken. Giessen: Brunnen.         [ Links ]

SPENER, P.J. 1841. Pia Desideria: oder herzliches Verlangen nach gottgefälliger Besserung der wahren evangelischen Kirche, nebst einigen dahin abzweckenden christlichen Vorschlägen. Leipzig: Köhler.         [ Links ]

TANASYAH, Y. & BUENTING, D. 2002. Connexity focuses on females. http://www.ywam.org/articles/article.asp?AID=137 Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

TUCKER, R.A. 1988. Guardians of the great commission: the story of women in modern missions. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.         [ Links ]

TUCKER, R.A. & LIEFELD, W.L. 1987. Daughters of the church: women and ministry from New Testament times to the present. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.         [ Links ]

UNIVERSITY OF THE NATIONS. 1995. University of the Nations school leader's reference guide. Lausanne: University of the Nations.         [ Links ]

UNIVERSITY OF THE NATIONS. 2005a. 2005 University of the Nations reference guide. Lausanne: University of the Nations. (In University of the Nations: resource tools. Lausanne: University of the Nations. [CDROM].         [ Links ])

UNIVERSITY OF THE NATIONS. 2005b. YWAM Mercy Ministries International: justice, gender and life-span issues, and best practices in member care. Lausanne: University of the Nations. (In University of the Nations. 2005 University of the Nations reference guide. Lausanne: University of the Nations. p. 343-350.         [ Links ])

UofN see UNIVERSITY OF THE NATIONS        [ Links ]

VAN DEVENTER, H.J.M. 2005. Why minds are changed: an inquiry into the decisions by the Gereformeerde Kerke in Suid-Afrika (GKSA) on the role of women in the church. Koers, 70(4):685-704.         [ Links ]

WINTER, B.W. 2001. After Paul left Corinth: the influence of secular ethics and social change. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

WINTER, B.W. 2003. Roman wives, Roman widows: the appearance of new women and the Pauline communities. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

YOUTH WITH A MISSION. s.a.a. About YWAM. http://www.ywam.org/contents/abo_introduction.htm Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

YOUTH WITH A MISSION. s.a.b. Founders - Loren and Darlene Cunningham. http://www.ywam.org/contents/abo_wha_founder.htm Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

YOUTH WITH A MISSION. s.a.c. Manila Covenant. http://www.ywam.org/contents/abo_doc_manila.htm Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

YOUTH WITH A MISSION. s.a.d. The foundational values of Youth With A Mission. http://www.ywam.org/contents/abo_doc_values.htm Date of access: 12 Aug. 2009.         [ Links ]

YWAM see YOUTH WITH A MISSION        [ Links ]

 

 

1 The research on which this article is based was undertaken while F.A.S. Hornstra-Fuchs was registered as an M.Th. student in the then Department of Systematic Theology and Theological Ethics at the University of South Africa.

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License