SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

vol.33 número2An information system to manage the rollout of the antiretroviral treatment programme in the Free State índice de autoresíndice de assuntospesquisa de artigos
Home Pagelista alfabética de periódicos  

Serviços Personalizados



Links relacionados

  • Em processo de indexaçãoCitado por Google
  • Em processo de indexaçãoSimilares em Google



versão On-line ISSN 2223-6279
versão impressa ISSN 0379-8577

Curationis vol.33 no.2 Pretoria Jan. 2010




Exploring the challenges of implementing participatory action research in the context of HIV and poverty



WA RosenthalI; DD KhalilII

ISchool of Nursing, University of the Western Cape
IIPhD MPA RN RNT. Division of Nursing & Midwifery University of Cape Town





HIV/AIDS is having a devastating impact on South Africa and particularly on poor communities. Empowerment of communities has been identified as an important step towards mitigating the consequences and helping communities to overcome the challenges presented. Participatory Action Research (PAR) has been identified as a useful methodology for the purpose of facilitating empowerment. This study explores the challenges involved in implementing PAR in the context of HIV/AIDS and poverty. In this article, the author describes a PAR project that took place in 2003/ 2004 with a group of five Xhosa speaking people living with HIV/AIDS in Masiphumelele, Cape Town. The aims of the study were to: 1. Create an opportunity for the participants to engage in a participatory process aimed at self-awareness and empowerment. 2. To record and analyse this process with the intention of producing insight into the use of PAR in the context of poverty and HIV/AIDS and to identify the challenges involved.
The findings of this study highlight some important insights into the process of engaging people in the PAR process and the experiences of HIV positive people living in the context of poverty. The study explores the challenges involved in the process of empowerment and examines the process of "transferring" power and control from the researcher to the participants. Challenges were uncovered both from the point of view of the researcher who had to "let go of control" and participants who had to take on control. Participants struggled with issues of low self-efficacy and learned helplessness. Fluctuations in health also contributed towards alternating periods of hope and despair and these problems had an impact on their motivation to participate in the study. Lack of motivation to participate is a challenge highlighted in the literature and explored in this study. Participation is necessary for a study of this nature to be of benefit to the community, but unfortunately those most in need were found to be least likely to participate.
The study also critically examines the research process that was conducted and highlights the positive and negative contribution of the process towards empowerment. Certain aspects of the research process, including the contracting process, were identified as being problematic as they emphasize the power and control of the researcher rather than the participants. Recommendations for future research include: Promoting participation among the disempowered; the Contracting process and Power relations in PAR.

Key words: Participatory Action Research, HIV/ AIDS, empowerment



“Full text available only in PDF format”




BABBIE, E & MOUTON, J 2001: The practice of social research. Cape Town: Oxford University Press.         [ Links ]

BANDURA, A 1997: Self-efficacy. Harvard mental health letter. 13(9):4-6, March.         [ Links ]

BRUGGE, D & KOLE, A 2003: Acase study of community-based participatory research ethics: the healthy public housing initiative. Science and engineering ethics. 9:485-501.         [ Links ]

CORNWALL, A & JEWKES, R 1995: What is participatory research? Social science and medicine. 41(12):1667-1676.         [ Links ]

CHIU, LF 2003: Transformational potential of focus group practice in participatory action research. Action research. 1(2):165-183.         [ Links ]

COCHRANE, J 2003: The experience of uncertainty for individuals with HIV/ AIDS. International journal of palliative nursing. 9(9):382-388.         [ Links ]

COCKBURN, L & TRENTHAM, B 2002: Participatory action research: integrating community occupational therapy practice and research. Canadian journal of occupational therapy. 21-31, February.         [ Links ]

COUNCIL FOR INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS OF MEDICAL SCIENCES (CIOMS) 1993: International ethical guidelines for biomedical research involving human subjects. Geneva: Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences.         [ Links ]

CRESWELL, JW 1998: Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five traditions. London: Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

FLICK, U 2002: An introduction to qualitative research. 2nd edition. London: Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

GARNER, D 1991: Interpreting. (In Ely, M, ed, 1999: Doing qualitative research: circles within circles. London: Falmer Press, p. 139-178.         [ Links ])

GRAY, RE; FITCH, M; DAVIS, C & PHILLIPS, C 2000: Challenges of participatory research: reflections on a study with breast cancer self-help groups. Health expectations. 3:243-252.         [ Links ]

KAPLAN, S & ALSUP, R 1995: Participatory action research: a response to AIDS prevention in diverse communities. Convergence. 28(1):38-56.         [ Links ]

KESBY, M 2000: Participatory diagramming as a means to improve communication about sex in rural Zimbabwe: a pilot study. Social science and medicine. 50(12):1723-1741.         [ Links ]

KOCH, T & KRALIK, D 2001: Chronic illnesses: reflections on a community-based action research programme. Journal of advanced nursing. 36(1):23-31.         [ Links ]

KOCH, T; SELIM, P; & KRALIK, D 2002: Enhancing lives through the development of a community-based, participatory action research programme. Journal of clinical nursing. 11(1):109-112, January.         [ Links ]

KYLMÄ, J; VEHVILÄINEN-JULKUNEN, K & LÄHDEVIRTA, J 2001: Dynamically fluctuating hope, despair and hopelessness along the HIV/AIDS continuum as described by caregivers in voluntary organisations in Finland. Issues in mental health nursing, 22:353-377.         [ Links ]

LINCOLN, YS & GUBA, EG 1985: Naturalistic inquiry. London: Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

LOW, J; SHELLEY, J&O'CONNOR, M 2000: Problematic success: an account of top-down participatory action research with women with multiple schlerosis. Field methods. 12(1): 29-48, February.         [ Links ]

LINDSEY, E; STAJDUHAR, K & MCGUINNESS, L 2001: Examining the process of community development. Journal of advanced nursing. 33(6):828-835.         [ Links ]

LYONS, M 1998: The impact of HIV and AIDS on children, families and communities: risks and realities of childhood during the HIV epidemic. United Nations Development Programme: HIV and Development Programme. Issues Paper 30. Accessed 9 March 2009        [ Links ]

MABALA, R & ALLEN, K 2002: Participatory action research on HJV/AIDS through a popular theatre approach in Tanzania. Evaluation and program planning. 25(4):333-339.         [ Links ]

MASON, J 2002: Qualitative researching. 2nd edition. London: Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

MEYER, JE 1993: Newparadigm research in practice: the trials and tribulations of action research. Journal of advanced nursing. 18:1066-1072.         [ Links ]

MORGAN, J 2001: Boxes and remembering in the time of AIDS. AIDS bulletin, 10(2):17-20.         [ Links ]

NELSON, N & WRIGHT, S 1995: Power and participatory development: theory and practice. London: Intermediate Technology Publications.         [ Links ]

PATTON, MQ 1987. Howto use qualitative methods in evaluation. Los Angeles : Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

PERAKYLA, A 1997: Reliability and validity in research based on transcriptions. (In Silverman D, ed. 1997: Qualitative research: theory methods and practice. London: Sage Publications, p. 201-220.         [ Links ])

POLLOCK, LC 1991: Qualitative analysis. (In Cormack, DFS, ed. 1991 : The research process in nursing. 2nd edition. Oxford: Blackwell Science Ltd, p. 293-302.         [ Links ])

POPE, C; ZIEBLAND, S & MAYS, N 1999: Analysing qualitative data. (In Pope, C & Mays, N, eds. 1999: Qualitative research in health care. 2nd edition. Bristol: BMJ Books, p. 75-88.         [ Links ])

PRESTBY, JE; WANDERSMAN, A; FLORIN, P; RICH, R & CHAVIS, D 1990: Benefits, costs, incentive management and participation in voluntary organizations: a means to understanding and promoting empowerment. American journal of community psychology, 18(1): 117-149.         [ Links ]

PRILLELTENSKY, I; NELSON, G & PEIRSON, L 2001: The role of power and control in children's lives: an ecological analysis of pathways toward wellness, resilience and problems. Journal of community and applied social psychology. 11:143-158.         [ Links ]

REARDON, K; WELSH, J; KREISWIRTH, B & FORESTER J 1993: Participatory action research from the inside: community development practice in East St. Louis. American sociologist. 24(1): 69-92, Spring.         [ Links ]

REID, C 2004: Advancing women's social justice agendas: a feminist action research framework. International Journal of qualitative methods. 3(3): 1-22, September.         [ Links ]

STEWART, R & BHAGWANJEE, A 1999: Promoting group empowerment and self-reliance through participatory research: a case study of people with physical disability. Disability and rehabilitation, 21(7):338-345.         [ Links ]

STRINGER, E 1999: Action research. 2nd edition. London: Sage Publications.         [ Links ]

VAN DER VLIET, V 1996: The politics of AIDS. London: Bowerdean Publishing Company Ltd.         [ Links ]

ZIMMERMAN, MA 1990: Toward a theory of learned hopefulness: a structural model analysis of participation and empowerment. Journal of research in personality. 24:71-86.         [ Links ]

ZUBER-SKERRITT, O 2001: Action learning, action research and process management: theory, practice, praxis. Brisbane: Action Research Unit, Faculty of Education, Griffith University.         [ Links ]



Mrs. Wendy Rosenthal
Address: Postnet 114
Private Bag XI8, Rondebosch, 7701
Tel: (021)959-3482

Creative Commons License Todo o conteúdo deste periódico, exceto onde está identificado, está licenciado sob uma Licença Creative Commons