Transcontinental reflections in the revised South African History curriculum on globalism and national narratives

 

 

Elize S Van Eeden

School of Basic Science, North-West University (Vaal Triangle Campus)

 

 

---

ABSTRACT

The early twenty-first century evidenced a worldwide change in History teaching through the means of several revised History curricula in the further education and training (FET) phase (high schools) and the developments of textbooks as a result of this. In South Africa, these trends have coincided with a period of educational transformation since the African National Congress took over as the leading political party in 1994. After close to 15 years, the transformational outcome also marked a change in the approach to History in the school curriculum and textbooks. This paper is structured to concisely debate globalisation and national narratives as foci in South Africa's revised History curriculum within current transcontinental reflections in history teaching. The implementation of these aspects in the revised South African History curriculum in the FET phase for specifically the Grade 12 level regarding textbook writing is only shortly discussed, accentuated, and critically analysed.

---

 

 

“Full text available only in PDF format”

 

 

References

MW APPLE & LK CHRISTIAN-SMITH, (Ed). (1991). The politics of the textbook (Routledge: New York).         [ Links ]

K ASMAL, (2007). "Keynote address: Interrogating the History Curriculum after ten years of OBE" (SASHT Conference, KwaZulu-Natal, 21-22 September), pp. 7-14.         [ Links ]

K ASMAL & J WILMOT, (ca 2001). "Education and democracy in South Africa today", pp. 185-204.         [ Links ]

J BAM, (1993). J Bam, Considerations for a new history curriculum for secondary schools in. South Africa (Cape Town, M. Ed., UCT) as in www.info.gov.za/otherdocs/2000/hapanelr.pdf.         [ Links ]

LD BEUKES; LJ DE JAGER; A ENGELBRECHT; A NIEMANN; R SWART; CN VAN DER WESTHUIZEN, (2008). "Changes and continuities in history textbooks after apartheid", Draft article copy presented for peer reviewing to the South African Journal of Education, pp. 1-32.         [ Links ]

L CALLINICOS, (1991). Popularising history in a changing South Africa. South African historical journal, 25:22-37.         [ Links ]

L CHISHOLM & R LEYENDECKER, (2008). Curriculum reform in post 1990's sub Saharan Africa. International Journal of Educational Development, 28(2), pp. 195-205.         [ Links ]

P CHRISTIE, (1996). Globalisation and the curriculum: Proposals for the integration of education and training in South Africa. International Journal of Educational Development, 16(4). pp. 407-416.         [ Links ]

C COFFIN, (2006). Historical discourse (British Library: London), pp. 1-208.         [ Links ]

EA COLE & J BARSALOU, (2006). "Unite or divide? The challenges of teaching history in societies emerging from violent conflict", United States Institute of Peace, Special Report 163, June, pp. 1-16.         [ Links ]

G CUTHBERTSON & A GRUNDLINGH, (1992). Some problematical issues in the restructuring of history education in South African schools. South African historical journal, 26:154-171.         [ Links ]

DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, South Africa (2003). National Curriculum Statement, History, pp. 22-33.         [ Links ]

P DE VILLIERS, (2008). E-mail interview with ES van Eeden, 23 February.         [ Links ]

S DRYDEN-PETERSON & R SIEBÖRGER, (2006). Teachers as memory makers: Testimony in the making of a new history in South Africa. International Journal of Educational Development, 26(4), July, pp. 394-403.         [ Links ]

RE DUNN, (Ed.), (1999). The New World History: A Teacher's Companion (Boston, MA:Bedford/St Martin's), pp. 230-241.         [ Links ]

A ECKER, (2008). "The structures and standards of initial training for History teachers - results of the first comparative study on a European level", (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

D HAMMETT, (2007). Constructing ambiguous identities: Negotiating race, respect and social change in "Coloured" Schools in Cape Town, South Africa, http://hdl.handle.net/1842/2084 as retrieved in 11 February 2008, pp. 1-3.         [ Links ]

W HASBERG, (2008). "Jeopardies and opportunities regarding empirical research for historical learning", (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

T HAYDN; R HARRIS, (2008). "Children's ideas about what it means 'to get better' at History: A view from the UK", (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

HISTORY EDUCATION GROUP (1993). History Matters: Debates about a new history curriculum for South Africa, University of Cape Town: Heinemann-Centaur.         [ Links ]

J JANSEN, (2002). Curriculum reconstruction in post-Colonial Africa: A Review of the literature, International Journal of Educational Development, pp. 1-2.         [ Links ]

D JOHNSON & F STEWART, (2007). Education, ethnicity and conflict. International Journal of Educational Development, 27(3), pp. 247-251.         [ Links ]

PH KAPP, (1992). "The place and role of History in the New Syllabus", US [Draft Report]        [ Links ]

H KLUG, (2000). Constituting democracy. Law, globalism and South Africa's political reconstruction (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).         [ Links ]

JA LASPINA, (2003). Designing diversity: globalization, textbooks, and the story of nations. Journal for Curriculum Studies, (35)6, pp. 667-696.         [ Links ]

CA LOCKARD, (2000). Global history, modernization, and the world-system approach; a critique. In        [ Links ]

R LAWSON, (2003). Black teachers (re) negotiation and (re) construction of their pedagogical practice within South Africa's post-apartheid curriculum (Ph.D., Ohio State University), pp. 1-170.         [ Links ]

D LINDMARK, (2008), "Empirical research in the teaching and learning of History in Sweden", (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

G MAZABOW, (2003). "The development of historical consciousness in the teaching of History in South African schools", (Ph.D., Unisa, Pretoria), pp. 1.-304.         [ Links ]

GR MORK, (2008). "Auditing and redesigning Advance Placement History in the USA: Reforms based upon empirical considerations of History Education", (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

J NICHOLLS, (ca 2003). "Methods in school textbook research".         [ Links ]

T NUTTALL; J WRIGHT; J HOFFMAN; N SISHI and S KHANDLELA, (1998). From apartheid to democracy: South Africa, 1948-1994, (Shuter & Shooter, Pietermaritzburg), pp. 1-134.         [ Links ]

SAPA, (2000). "Give more time to History", Educ-History, Pretoria, December 14.         [ Links ]

R SIEBÖRGER, (2008). "Don't deprive pupils of chance to study history", Cape Times, 12 June, p. 9;         [ Links ] "Don't rob pupils of our rich history", The Star, 19 June, p. 19.         [ Links ]

PN STEARNS; P SEIXAS and S WINEBURG, (ed) (2000). Knowing teaching & learning history (New York: New York University Press). pp. 1-477.         [ Links ]

E THERON, (1983). Sonder hoed of handskoen (Tafelberg, Kaapstad).         [ Links ]

E THERON & JB DU TOIT, (1971). Kortbegrip van die Theron-verslag (Tafelberg, Kaapstad).         [ Links ]

J TULLY, (1995). Strange Multipicity: Constitutionalism in an Age of Diversity (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).         [ Links ]

N TUTIAUX-GUILLON, (2008). "Researches in history didactics about learning: Methodologies for analyzing results and bringing to the fore processes" (ISHD/IGGD Conference, Tuzing, Germany, 8-10 September 2008).         [ Links ]

A VAN DER MERWE, A VERMAAK & S LOMBARD, (1991). An empirical investigation into the teaching of History in the RSA. (Pretoria: Human Sciences Research Council, HSRC Education Research Programme no.19, 232p.         [ Links ]).

ES VAN EEDEN, (1997). "Historiographical and methodological trends in the teaching of History in a changing South Africa", Historia, November.         [ Links ]

ES VAN EEDEN, (1998). "An approach to the teaching of universal global history concepts in world history practice in South Africa", International World History Bulletin, XIV(1), Spring.         [ Links ]

ES VAN EEDEN, (1999). Didactical guidelines for teaching History in a changing South Africa (Keurkopie: Potchefstroom), pp. 1-450.         [ Links ]

ES VAN EEDEN & T VERMEULEN, (2005). "Christian National Education and People's Education: Historical perspectives on some common grounds", New Contree, 50, (March).         [ Links ]

ES VAN EEDEN & JL VAN DER WALT, (2000). Creating a future for History within South Africa's 'Curriculum 2005', Journal for Theory and Research in Social Education, Birmingham, USA, 28(1), Winter, pp. 85-95.         [ Links ]

WP VISSER, (1993). People's history en Geskiedenisonderrig op skool: 'n alternatiewe geskiedenis vir die nuwe Suid-Afrika. Gister en vandag, 25:32-39, Mei.         [ Links ]

G WELDON, (2006). A comparative study on the construction of memory and identity in the curriculum of post-conflict societies: Rwanda and South Africa, http://www.centres.ex.ac.uk/historyresource/iournal11/..., pp. 1-16.         [ Links ]

G WELDON, (2008). "History education and the democratic nation in post-apartheid South Africa", Conference, South African Society for History Teaching (SASHT), 26-27 September.         [ Links ]

PG WARNICH, (2008). "Uitkomsgebaseerde assessering van Geskiedenis in Graad 10". (Potchefstroom NWU, PhD), pp. 187; 212-221.         [ Links ]

WIKIPEDIA SEARCH ENGINE (2008) www.Wikipedia.org.         [ Links ]

J WILMOT & K ASMAL, Ed. (2000). Values, Education and Democracy, Department of Education, Cape Town.         [ Links ]

YESTERDAY & TODAY, (2006). Special edition, March (covers articles on the current History debate, OBE utilizing and curriculum changes in South Africa). Also available on http://www.sashtw.org.za.         [ Links ]

YESTERDAY & TODAY, (2007). 1, May, (covers articles on the current History debate, OBE utilizing and curriculum changes in South Africa). Also available on http://www.sashtw.org.za.         [ Links ]

YESTERDAY & TODAY, (2008). 2, May, (covers articles on the current History debate, OBE utilizing and curriculum changes in South Africa). Also available on http://www.sashtw.org.za.         [ Links ]

BG YUILL, (2002). "The History workshop's teacher conferences, past and present assessment of its educational value", (M.A. - University of the Witwatersrand).         [ Links ]