SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

vol.13 issue1On merger simulation and its potential role in South African merger controlCapital budgeting practices used by selected listed South African firms author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

South African Journal of Economic and Management Sciences

On-line version ISSN 2222-3436
Print version ISSN 1015-8812

S. Afr. j. econ. manag. sci. vol.13 n.1 Pretoria Jan. 2010




Making sense of the disclosure of latent defects in financial statements and company acquisition contracts



Cornelius Kilian

Former Interim Researcher at the European Academy (EURAC). Centre for Financial Planning Law, University of the Free State




This paper analyses the statement made by the South African Appeal Court Judge Holmes in the Phame v Paizes (1973) case and, using economic and unique South African legal principles, it examines the true legal nature of a contract to regulate company acquisitions.1 Two solutions are offered for financial managers in South Africa: (1) the contract to regulate company acquisitions is a forward contract and (2) the difficulty in identifying latent defects should not be grounds for reducing the price paid for a company or enterprise in the South African legal system.

JEL: G34, K20



“Full text available only in PDF format”




ANTHONY, D. 2004. Rethinking the rules of financial accounting. New York.         [ Links ]

ARNOLD, G. 2005. The handbook of corporate finance. London: Prentice Hall.         [ Links ]

BLACK, A., WRIGHT, P. & DAVIES, J. 2001. In search of shareholder value (2nd ed.) London: Prentice Hall.         [ Links ]

BLOOMFIELD, S. 2000. Reading between the lines of company accounts. s.n.         [ Links ]

BOUCKAERT, B. & DE GEEST, G. (eds.) 2001. Encyclopedia of law and economics, vol 2. Great Britain: MPG Books.         [ Links ]

CILLIERS, H.S., BENADE, M.L., HENNING, J.J., DU PLESSIS, J.J., DELPORT, P.A., DE KOKER, L. & PRETORIUS, J.T 2000. Corporate law (3rd ed.) Durban: Butterworth.         [ Links ]

CORREIA, C., FLYNN, D., ULIANA, E. & WORMALD, M. 2007. Financial management. (6th ed.) Cape Town: Juta & Co.         [ Links ]

DAUBE, D. 1959. Studies in the Roman law of sale in memory of Francis de Zulueta. Oxford: University Press.         [ Links ]

DU PLESSIS, J.J., MCCONVILL, J. & BAGARIC, M. 2005. Principles of contemporary corporate governance. Cambridge: University Press.         [ Links ]

ERNST & YOUNG, Reporting auditors group. 2006. International GAAP 2007. LexisNexis.         [ Links ]

EXTENSIBLE COMPANY REPORTING LANGUAGE.2009. What is XBRL? (Hitting what is XBRL button).         [ Links ] [online]. Available at [Accessed 18 March 2009].

GLOBAL REPORTING INITIATIVE. 2009. About GRI. (Hitting about GRI button).         [ Links ][online]. Available at [Accessed 18 March 2009].

HAVENGA, M. 1997. Fiduciary duties of company directors with specific regard to corporate opportunities. LLD thesis: UNISA.         [ Links ]

HIEMSTRA, V.G. & GONIN, H.L. 2000. Trilingual legal dictionary. (3rd ed.) Cape Town: Juta and Co.         [ Links ]

HURTER, E. 1988. Die regsposisie van die koper van ongenoteerde aandele in die geval van verborge gebreke en wanvoorstelling. Modern Company Law: 134-141.         [ Links ]

INSPIRED TASK FORCE. 2009. About Edgar. (Hitting about Edgar button).         [ Links ][online]. Available at [Accessed 18 March 2009].

KERR, A.J. 1996. The principles of the law of contract. (2nd ed.) Durban: Butterworth.         [ Links ]

KERR, A.J. 2002. The principles of the law of contract. (6th ed.) Durban: Butterworth.         [ Links ]

KILIAN, C.G. 2009. Auctions of private companies - In brief, the legal position in South Africa and the United Kingdom. The Company Lawyer: 82-86.         [ Links ]

KILIAN, C.G. 2005. The legal nature of the company's constitution and the incidence of ordinary damages. The Company Lawyer: 154-157.         [ Links ]

KILIAN, C.G. & DU PLESSIS, J.J. 2005. Possible remedies for shareholders when a company refuses to declare dividends or declare inadequate dividends. Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg, 1: 48-65        [ Links ]

MCGREGOR'S. 2002 Security exchange digest, the complete South African investor's guide to shares & unit trusts. (7th ed.) Carla Soares Press.         [ Links ]

MOMMSEN, T & KRUGER, P. (eds.) 1954. Corpus iuris civilis, digesta 181 81. Berlin.         [ Links ]

MosTERT, D.F., JouBERT, D.J. & VILJoEN, g. 1972 Die koopkontrak. Durban: Butterworth. PHAME v PAIZES 1973 (3) SA 397 (A).         [ Links ]


SOUTH AFRICA. 1995. Labour Relations Act, No. 66 of 1995. Pretoria: Government Printer [Laws].         [ Links ]

STEINER, R. 1998. Mastering financial calculations. London: Prentice Hall.         [ Links ]


VAN ZYL, D.H. 1977. Geskiedenis en beginsels van die romeinse privaatreg. Durban: Butterworth.         [ Links ]

VIGARIO, F. 2007. Managerial accounting and finance. (4th ed.) South Africa: Butterworths.         [ Links ]

VINTCENT, C. 1999. Be your own stock broker. (3rd ed.) London: Prentice Hall.         [ Links ]

VISSER, C., PRETORIUS, J.T., SHARROCK, R. & MISCHKE, C. 1997. Gibson's South African mercantile and company law. (7th ed.) Cape Town: Juta & Co.         [ Links ]

WALSH, C. 1996. Key management ratios. London: Prentice Hall.         [ Links ]

WEBSTER, E. & VON HOLDT, K. 2005. Beyond the apartheid workplace, studies in transition. University KwaZulu Natal: Press.         [ Links ]

World BUSINESS Council for Sustainable Development. 2009. About WBCSD. (Hitting about WBCSD).         [ Links ][online]. Available at 1&ClickMenu=LeftMenu [Accessed 18 March 2009].



Accepted July 2009




1 I am grateful to Dr. David Levey and two anonymous referees for useful and helpful comments on an earlier draft of this contribution.
2 The quality of a company is observed by means of reliable financial methods or ratios which are capable of being compared with those of other companies in the same economic sphere. Bloomfield (2000) states that these methods or ratios must be universally acclaimed, otherwise good company qualities become just another synonym for hoodwink. Steiner (1998) indicates that these methods usually make use of profitability to calculate investment attractiveness.
3 My inclusion.

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License