ORIGINAL RESEARCH

 

The doctrines of original sin and the virgin birth: Divine revelation or human construct?

 

 

I J J Spangenberg

University of South Africa

 

 

---

ABSTRACT

Two South African theologians, Ben du Toit and Anton van Niekerk, recently published books in which they argued that postmodern believers can no longer subscribe to the doctrines of original sin and the virgin birth. According to them both these doctrines reflect a premodern world-view which should be regarded as outdated. However, they would not like to take leave of the grand narrative of Christianity. There are some fundamental flaws in the reasoning of both scholars. The doctrine of the virgin birth is intertwined with the doctrine of original sin, and both are important to the orthodox doctrine of salvation. As it is not viable or consistent to tamper with some of the orthodox doctrines and try to keep the rest intact, we are left with two options, either to discard the whole system and start afresh, or to try and keep the whole package intact. However, biblical research since the Enlightenment has ruled out the second option. The paper argues in support of this case and attempts to offer a different way forward for Christians living in the twenty-first century than the one offered by Du Toit and Van Niekerk.

---

 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

 

Consulted literature

Bandstra, B 1995. Reading the Old Testament: An introduction to the Hebrew Bible. New York: Wadsworth.         [ Links ]

Barr, J 1992. The Garden of Eden and the hope of immortality. London: SCM.         [ Links ]

Bavinck, H 1932. Handleiding bij het onderwijs in den Christelijken Godsdienst. Kampen: Kok.         [ Links ]

Benjamin, D C 1997. Stories of Adam and Eve in Sun, H T C & Eades, K L (eds), Problems in biblical theology: Essays in honor of Rolf Knierim. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 38-58.         [ Links ]

Bosman, H L 1983. Psalm 51:7 en erfsonde. NGTT 24, 264-271.         [ Links ]

Brown, R E 1999. Virginal conception of Jesus, in Richardson, A & Bowden, J (eds) A new dictionary of Christian theology. London: SCM, 597-598.         [ Links ]

Carroll, R P 1991. Wolf in the sheepfold: The Bible as a problem for Christianity. London: SPCK.         [ Links ]

Crenshaw, J L 2001. The Psalms: An introduction. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

Durand, J J F 1978. Die sonde. Pretoria: NG Kerkboekhandel (Wegwysers in die dogmatiek).         [ Links ]

Du Toit, B 2000. God? Geloof in 'npostmoderne tyd. Bloemfontein: CLF.         [ Links ]

Ehrman, B D 2008. The New Testament: A historical introduction to the early Christian writings. 4^th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.         [ Links ]

Eloff, J N 1975. Die dilemma van die moderne Christenbioloog: Intreerede gelewer op 6Mei 1975. Bloemfontein: UOVS.         [ Links ]

Fokkelman, J P 2001. Reading Biblical poetry: An introductory guide. Louisville: Westminster John Knox.         [ Links ]

-, 2002. The Psalms in form. Leiden: Deo (Tools for Biblical Study Series, 4).         [ Links ]

Freeman, C 2003. The closing of the Western mind: The rise of faith and the fall of reason. London: Pimlico.         [ Links ]

Gillingham, S E 1994. The poems and psalms of the Hebrew Bible. Oxford: Oxford University Press (The Oxford Bible Series).         [ Links ]

Hoffmann, R J 1993. Afterword, in Smith, M & Hoffmann, R J (ed), What the Bible really says. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 239-243.         [ Links ]

Käsemann, E 1974. An die Römer. Tübingen: Mohr (Handbuch zum Neuen Testament, 8a).         [ Links ]

Klutz, T 2000. The value of being virginal: Mary and Anna in the Lukan infancy prologue, in Brooke, G J (ed), The birth of Jesus: Biblical and theological reflections. Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 71-87.         [ Links ]

Lampe, G W H 2003. Christian theology in the patristic period, in Cunliffe-Jones, H (ed), A history of Christian doctrine. London: Continuum, 21-180.         [ Links ]

New Jerusalem Bible 1985. London: Darton, Longman & Todd.         [ Links ]

Ormerod, N 1992. Grace and disgrace: A theology of self-esteem, society, and history. Newtown (Australia): E J Dwyer.         [ Links ]

Pelikan, J & Hotchkiss, V 2003. Creeds and confessions of faith in the Christian tradition: Volume II, Part Four: Creeds and confessions of the Reformation era. New Haven: Yale University Press.         [ Links ]

Primavesi, A 1991. From Apocalypse to Genesis: Ecology, feminism and Christianity. Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg Fortress.         [ Links ]

Primavesi, A 2000. Theology and earth system science, in Parsons, S F (ed), Challenging women's orthodoxies in the context of faith. Hants: Ashgate, 21-34.         [ Links ]

Revised English Bible 1989. Oxford: Oxford University Press.         [ Links ]

Richardson, A & Bowden, J (eds) 1999. A new dictionary of Christian theology. London: SCM.         [ Links ]

Rosenberg, D & Bloom, H 1990. The Book of J. New York: Weidenfeld.         [ Links ]

Seybold, K 1997. Introducing the Psalms. Edinburgh: T&T Clark.         [ Links ]

Sisemore, T A 2004. From doctrine to practice: The influence of the doctrine of original sin on Puritan child rearing, in Ratcliff, D (ed), Children's spirituality: Christian perspectives, research, and applications. Eugene: Cascade Books, 219-232.         [ Links ]

Slavenburg, J 1995. Valsheid in geschrifte: De gespleten pen van bijbelschrijvers. Zutphen: Walburg Pers.         [ Links ]

Smelik, K A D 2003. De dood en de Bijbel. Heerenveen: Jongbloed.         [ Links ]

Spangenberg, I J J 2003. Teologie op die markplein: 'n Post-apartheid teoloog dink na oor sy geloof en leefwêreld. Pretoria: C B Powell Bybelsentrum, UNISA.         [ Links ]

Spong, J S 1992. Born of a woman: A bishop rethinks the birth of Jesus. New York: HarperCollins.         [ Links ]

Theron, P F 2005. In sonde ontvang en gebore, sê wie? NGTT 46, 576-586.         [ Links ]

Tucker, G M 1978. The creation and the fall: A reconsideration. Lexington Theological Quarterly 13, 113-124.         [ Links ]

Van Niekerk, A A 2005. Geloof sonder sekerhede: Besinning vir eietydse gelowiges. Wellington: Lux Verbi.BM.         [ Links ]

Von Rad, G 1976. Genesis: A commentary. London: SCM (Old Testament Library).         [ Links ]

Weber, G 1998. I believe I doubt: Notes on Christian experience. London: SCM.         [ Links ]

Westermann, C 1972. Genesis 1-11. Darmstadt: WBG (Erträge der Forschung 7).         [ Links ]

Wiersinga, H 1992. Geloven bij daglicht: verlies en toekomst van een traditie. Kampen: Kok.         [ Links ]

Williams, R H 2002. An illustration of historical inquiry: Histories of Jesus and Matthew 1:1-25, in Blasi, A J, Duhaime, J & Turcotte, P-A (eds), Handbook of early Christianity: Social science approaches. Walnut Creek: AltaMira, 105-123.         [ Links ]

Zink, J 1997. Jörg Zink, in Moltmann, J (ed), How I have changed: Reflections on thirty years of theology. London: SCM, 55-64.         [ Links ]