SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

vol.29 issue2Confessional and ecumenical? Revisiting Edmund Schlink on the hermeneutics of doctrineEthics and Christology - Rediscovering Jesus in Evolutionary History author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Verbum et Ecclesia

On-line version ISSN 2074-7705
Print version ISSN 1609-9982

Verbum Eccles. (Online) vol.29 n.2 Pretoria  2008




God in de (Post) moderne cultuur - George Steiner over transcendentie in kunst en cultuur


God in the (Post) modern culture - George Steiner on transcendence in art and culture



W Stoker

Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam




In his 1989 study Real Presences the well-known philosopher and literary scholar George Steiner argues that there is a crisis in philosophy, art and literature. The contract between word and world has been broken, whereby we can no longer make any assertions about human beings and the world. Communication thus becomes problematic. The (post)modern world has become nihilistic. Steiner provides a theological explanation for what in his view is a serious crisis in (post)modern art and in Western culture in general: he blames this crisis for the loss of transcendence through the "death of God". This paper will show that Steiner, on the basis of his metaphysical view of transcendence ends up with the dilemma of having to choose between transcendence or immanence/nihilism. This dilemma is unnecessary to the extent that it suggests that transcendence is identical with metaphysical transcendence. If we reject this identification, then the alternative for Steiner's metaphysical transcendence is not only immanence, viewed as nihilism but can also be another form of transcendence. And this casts another light on the crisis Steiner has indicated in culture.



Full text available only in PDF format.




Altizer, Th. J J 1980. Total Presence: The Language of Jesus and The Language of Today. New York: The Seabury Press.         [ Links ]

De Boer, Th. 1999. Het spoor bijster, in De Boer Th. e.a. (reds.), De razende Socrates: hartstocht en rede in de filosofie van Socrates tot Derrida. Baarn/Kapellen: Agora Pelckmans.         [ Links ]

Dalferth, I U 2006. Becoming Present: An Inquiry into the Christian Sense of the Presence of God. Leuven: Peeters.         [ Links ]

Derrida, J 1981. The Double Session, in Derrida J. Dissemination, 187-316. London: Continuum.         [ Links ]

-, 1984. Deconstruction and the other: interview met R Kearny, in Kearny, R (ed.), Dialogues with contemporary continental thinkers. New York.         [ Links ]

-, 1987. Psyché: Invention de l'autre, Paris: Galilée.         [ Links ]

Evink, E 2002. Transcendentie en inscriptie: Jacques Derrida en de hubris van de metafysica. Delft: Eburon.         [ Links ]

Flaubert, G 1965. An Aesthetic Mysticism, in Ellmann R. & Feidelson C. The Modern Tradition: Backgrounds of Modern Literature, 193-198. New York: Oxford University Press.         [ Links ]

Kuschel, K-J, 1993. Gegenwart Gottes? Zur Möglichkeit theologischer Ästhetik in Auseinandersetzung mit George Steiner, in Lesch, W (Hg.). Theologie und Ästhetische Erfahrung: Beiträge zur Begegnung von Religion und Kunst, Darmstadt:Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 145165.         [ Links ]

Palmer, M F 1984. Paul Tillich's Philosophy of Art, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.         [ Links ]

Pater, W 1965. The intensity of the Moment, in Ellmann, R & Feidelson, C (eds), The Modern Tradition: Backgrounds of Modern Literature, New York: Oxford University Press, 182-185.         [ Links ]

Prosman, AAA 2007. Geloven na Nietzsche: Nietzsches nihilisme in de spiegel van de theologie. Zoetermeer: Boekencentrum.         [ Links ]

Rilke, R M 2000. Archaïsche Apollotorso, in Verstegen, P (vertaling) Nieuwe Gedichten: Het andere deel, 9. Amsterdam: Van Oorschot.         [ Links ]

Steiner, G 1991a. Real Presences, Chicago: The Chicago University Press.         [ Links ]

-, 1991b. Reële Presenties, in Steiner, G, Heeft waarheid een toekomst? Essays. Baarn: Ambo, 144-164.         [ Links ]

-, 1991c. Heidegger opnieuw, in Steiner, G, Heeft waarheid een toekomst? Essays. Baarn: Ambo, 165-189.         [ Links ]

-, 1994. A Responsion, in Scott, N A & Sharp, R A, Reading Steiner, Baltimore & London: The John Hopkins University, 275-285.         [ Links ]

Stoker, W 1996. Is the Quest for Meaning the Quest for God? The Religious Ascription of Meaning in Relation to the Secular Ascription of Meaning. Amsterdam/Atlanta: Rodopi.         [ Links ]

-, 2007. God Master in the Arts. vol1        [ Links ]

Taylor, M C 1992. Disfiguring: Art, Architecture, Religion. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.         [ Links ]

Tillich, P 1968. Systematic Theology, London: James Nisbet & Co.         [ Links ]

Van der Syde, N 1997. De visie op literatuur van Jacques Derrida. Groningen: Rijksuniversiteit.         [ Links ]



1 Navorsingsgenoot, Prof C J A Wethmar, Departement Dogmatiek en Christelike Etiek, Universiteit van Pretoria.

Creative Commons License All the contents of this journal, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License