versión On-line ISSN 2413-3051
J. energy South. Afr. vol.22 no.1 Cape Town 2011
Harald WinklerI; Andrew MarquardII
IEnergy Research Centre, University of Cape Town
IIEnergy Research Centre, University of Cape Town
A carbon tax should be considered among the range of instruments available to the South African government, economy and society, as part of a broad portfolio of mitigation actions. A carbon tax was one of the most effective wedges or mitigation options analysed for the Long-term mitigation scenarios (LTMS) for South Africa. The LTMS strategic option 'Using the market' reduced emissions roughly as required by Science, for several decades. The LTMS research indicated that the effectiveness increases, up to certain tax levels. South Africa might consider a tax starting around R100-200 / t CO2eq, escalating in future.
Our paper presents results on research on a carbon tax in South Africa conducted in 2008 and was presented at the Climate Change Summit 2009. The efficiency with which a carbon tax achieves the goal of reducing GHG emissions depends on responsiveness and substitutability. This is shown more fully on the supply-side, while further work will be needed to fully understand the response to a carbon tax on the demand side.
Careful design of a carbon tax (or other economic instruments considered) will be important to ensure that it is effective in meeting its objective -reducing GHG emissions. We propose a price discovery and adjustment mechanism that sets a band around the desired 'peak, plateau and decline' trajectory.
Equity demands that poor households, in particular, be shielded from any burden. Off-setting incentives, such as food subsidies or reduced VAT on basic goods, should in finance measure that which will ensure that the package of tax and incentives is a net benefit to the poor - and not to treat the tax as a revenue-raising instrument. With appropriate design, a carbon tax can be a powerful instrument of mitigation in South Africa, and at the same time, contribute to socio-economic objectives.
Keywords: carbon tax, South Africa, economic instruments, climate change mitigation, greenhouse gas emissions
Full text available only in pdf format.
This paper, derived from a report, is the result of collaboration between the Energy Research Centre (ERC), Environmental Policy Research Unit (EPRU) and Genesis Analytics. The ERC and EPRU are both research units at the University of Cape Town. The research by Genesis Analytics was commissioned by the ERC, drawing on National Research Foundation (NRF) funding which is gratefully acknowledged.
ANC (African National Congress) 2007. Resolution on climate change: ANC 52nd National Conference, Polokwane, Limpopo. www.anc.org.za/show.php?doc=ancdocs/history/jan8-08.html. [ Links ]
Anderson, M. S., (2004). Vikings and virtues: a decade of CO2 taxation. Climate Policy 4 (1): 13-24. [ Links ]
Anderson, M. S., (2008). Environmental and economic implications of taxing and trading carbon: Some European experiences. in J E Milne (Ed). The reality of carbon taxes in the 21st century. Vermont, Environmental Tax Policy Institute: 61-87. [ Links ]
Bond, P, (2000). Economic growth, ecological modernization or environmental justice? Conflicting discourses in South Africa today. Johannesburg, Municipal Services Project. CDC (2004). Investment opportunity. www.coega.co.za. [ Links ]
Den Elzen, M.; Höhne, N.; Lucas, P L.; Moltmann, S., & Kuramochi, T., (2007). The Triptych approach revisited: A staged sectoral approach for climate mitigation. MNP Report 500114008/ 2007. Bilthoven, Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (MNP). [ Links ]
DME (Department of Minerals & Energy) (2008). National response to South Africa's electricity shortage. Pretoria. [ Links ]
EDRC (Energy & Development Research Centre) (2003). Policies and measures for renewable energy and energy efficiency in South Africa. Prepared for the Sustainable Energy & Climate Change Partnership. Cape Town, EDRC, University of Cape Town. [ Links ]
Eunomia & UP (Eunomia research & consulting and University of Pretoria) (2004). Development of a framework for market-based instruments to support environmental fiscal reform in South Africa. A draft final report for National Treasury of South Africa. Not for citation. Pretoria, Treasury. [ Links ]
Fine, B.; & Rustomjee, Z.; (1996). The political economy of South Africa: from minerals-energy complex to industrialization. London, C. Hurst. [ Links ]
Fisher, J & Grubb, M 1997. The use of economic models in climate change policy analysis. 5. Royal Institute of International Affairs. October 1997. [ Links ]
Hughes, A.; Haw, M.; Winkler, H.; Marquard, A.; & Merven, B.; (2007). Energy emissions: A modelling input into the Long Term Mitigation Scenarios process. Prepared by the Energy Research Centre for Department of Environment Affairs and Tourism, Pretoria, October 2007. www.erc.uct.ac.za/Research/LTMS/LTMS-intro.htm Accessed 30 October 2008. [ Links ]
LCS (Low Carbon Society project) (2006). Developing visions for a Low-Carbon Society (LCS) through sustainable development. The first workshop of Japan-UK joint research project. Ibaraki, Japan, National Institute for Environmental Studies. [ Links ]
Manuel, T.; (2008). Budget speech, 20 February. Cape Town, Parliament. http://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2008/speech/speech.pdf Accessed 22 February 2008. [ Links ]
Manuel, T.; (2009). Budget speech, Minister of Finance. 11 February. Cape Town, Parliament. http://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2009/speech/speech.pdf Accessed 11 February 2009. [ Links ]
Michie, J.; & Padayachee, V.; (1998). Three years after Apartheid: Growth, employment and redistribution? Cambridge Journal of Economics 22: 623-635. [ Links ]
National Treasury (2003). Market-based instruments to support environmental fiscal reform in South Africa: A discussion document. Pretoria, National Treasury. [ Links ]
National Treasury (2006). A framework for considering market-based instruments to support environmental fiscal reform in South Africa. Draft policy paper. Pretoria, National Treasury Tax Policy Chief Directorate. www.treasury.gov.za/tax/default.htm. [ Links ]
Nedergaard, M.; (2002). The application of economic instruments in energy and climate change policies. Sustainable Energy & Climate Change Partnership: A project of WWF Denmark and Earthlife Africa Johannesburg. www.earthlife.org.za/Files/Economic%20instruments%20%20M%20Nedergaard%202002.pdf. Accessed on 15 May 2008. [ Links ]
NERSA (National Energy Regulator of South Africa) (2008). NIRP3 Stage 5: Risk & sensitivity analysis: Proposal for three diversified plans. 12 February. [ Links ]
Pacala, S.; & Socolow, R. H.; (2004). Stabilization wedges: Solving the climate problem for the next 50 years with current technologies. Science 305 (13 August): 968-972. [ Links ]
Pauw, K.; (2007). Economy-wide modelling: An input into the Long Term Mitigation Scenarios process, LTMS Input Report 4. Cape Town, Energy Research Centre. www.erc.uct.ac.za/Research/LTMS/LTMS-intro.htm. Accessed 30 October 2008. [ Links ]
Pearce, D.; (1991). The role of carbon taxes in adjusting to global warming. The Economic Journal 101: 938-948. [ Links ]
Raskin, P.; Gallopin, G.; Gutman, P.; Hammond, A.; & Swart, R.; (1998). Bending the curve: Toward global sustainability. A report of the Global Scenario Group. Boston, Stockholm Environment Institute. [ Links ]
SBT (Scenario Building Team) (2007). Long Term Mitigation Scenarios: Strategic Options for South Africa. Pretoria Department of Environment Affairs and Tourism. www.environment.gov.za/HotIssues/2008/LTMS/A%20LTMS%20Scenarios%20for%20SA.pdf. Accessed 15 October 2008. [ Links ]
Spalding-Fecher, R.; (2001). Energy and sustainability in South Africa: the 2001 Sustainable Energy Watch Report. Cape Town, Energy & Development Research Centre, University of Cape Town. [ Links ]
Tyler, E.; Dunn, Z.; du Toit, M.; & Raubenheimer, S.; (2008). Carbon regulatory options in South Africa: A business briefing note. Prepared for the National Business Initiative. Version 1.2. Cape Town, Genesis Analytics. [ Links ]
UNDP & GEF (United Nations Development Programme and Global Environmental Facility) (2002). Pioneering the low carbon future ... sustaining livelihoods: Experiences from GEF-UNDP projects in climate change and ozone depletion. New York. [ Links ]
UNFCCC (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change) (1997). Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Bonn, UNFCCC Secretariat. [ Links ]
van Heerden, J.; Gerlagh, R.; Blignaut, J.; Horridge, M.; Hess, S.; Mabugu, R.; & Mabugu, M.; (2006). Searching for triple dividends in South Africa: Fighting CO2 pollution and poverty while promoting growth. The Energy Journal 27 (2): 113-141. [ Links ]
van Schalkwyk, M.; (2008). Government outlines vision, strategic direction and framework for climate policy. Statement by Marthinus van Schalkwyk, Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism, 28 July. Cape Town. www.environment.gov.za. Accessed 29 July 2008. [ Links ]
Visser, M.; Spalding-Fecher, R.; & Leiman, A.; (1999). Manufacturing and economic growth. Paper No. 10: World Wildlife Fund Macroeconomic Reforms and Sustainable Development in Southern Africa Project. Cape Town, Energy & Development Research Centre, University of Cape Town. [ Links ]
Winkler, H. (Ed) (2007). Long Term Mitigation Scenarios: Technical Report. Prepared by the Energy Research Centre for Department of Environment Affairs and Tourism, Pretoria, October 2007. www.erc.uct.ac.za/Research/LTMS/LTMS-intro.htm. Accessed 30 October 2008. [ Links ]
Winkler, H.; (2009). Cleaner energy, cooler climate: Developing sustainable energy solutions for South Africa Cape Town, HSRC Press. [ Links ]
Winkler, H.; & Marquard, A.; (2007). Energy development and climate change in South Africa: Decarbonising growth in South Africa. Occasional paper 2007/40, for UNDP's Human Development Report 2007/8: Fighting climate change: Human solidarity in a divided world. New York, Human Development Report Office. http://hdr.undp.org/en/reports/global/hdr2007-2008/papers/winkler_harald%20and%20mar-quard_andrew.pdf. Accessed 29 January 2008. [ Links ]
Zipplies, R. (Ed) (2009). Bending the curve: Your guide to tackling climate change in South Africa. Contributors: R Zipplies. Cape Town, Africa Geographic. [ Links ]
Received 16 March 2009
Revised 25 September 2009