The Church as a peace broker: The case of the Natal Church Leaders' Group and political violence in KwaZulu-Natal (1990 - 1994)

 

 

Michael Mbona

School of Religion and Theology, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Pietermaritzburg, South Africa

 

 

---

ABSTRACT

Moves by the state to reform the political landscape in South Africa at the beginning of 1990 led to increased tension between the Inkatha Freedom Party and the African National Congress in the province of Natal and the KwaZulu homeland. Earlier efforts by the Natal Church Leaders' Group to end hostilities through mediation had yielded minimal results. Hopes of holding the first general democratic election in April 1994 were almost dashed due to Inkatha's standoff position until the eleventh hour. This article traces the role played by church leaders in seeking to end the bloody clashes taking place at that time by engaging with the state and the rival political parties between 1990 and 1994. Despite the adoption of new strategies, challenges such as internal divisions, blunders at mediation, and the fact that the church leaders were also "political sympathisers", hampered progress in achieving peace. While paying tribute to the contribution of other team players, this article argues that an ecumenical initiative was responsible for ending the politically motivated brutal killings in KwaZulu-Natal in the early years of 1990.

---

 

 

“Full text available only in PDF format”

 

 

Works consulted

Oral sources

Aitchison, John. Interviewed by author in Pietermaritzburg, 18 August 2008.         [ Links ]

Kearney, Paddy. Interviewed by author in Pietermaritzburg, 21 August 2008.         [ Links ]

Kerchhoff, Joan. Interviewed by author in Pietermaritzburg, 22 August 2008.         [ Links ]

Mkhize, Dorcas. Interviewed by author in Pietermaritzburg, 13 October 2008.         [ Links ]

Nuttall, Michael. Interviewed by author in Pietermaritzburg, 10 October 2007.         [ Links ]

Archival sources

• Natal Diocesan Archives, Pietermaritzburg (DN).

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.2, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 7 May 1988.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.23, Minutes of the NCLG meeting, 3 July 1989.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.81, Minutes of NCLG special meeting, 26 January 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.82, The Natal Crisis, Memorandum presented by John Aitchison to Minister of Law and Order, 29 January 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.114, Synopsis of NCLG delegation and State President meeting, 11 April 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.122, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 28 April 1990.         [ Links ]

DN, STF to all Ministers and Clergy in Pietermaritzburg, Re: Joint mass action 2-7 July 1990, 22 June 1990 (not indexed).         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.140, STF to the Honourable State President, Re: Mass action 2-7 July 1990, c.a. June 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.142, South African Council of Churches: press statement and code of conduct during the week of public demonstrations, 27 June 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.64, Dr F T Mdlalose to the Right Reverend Michael Nuttall, Re: peace talks between UDF/COSATU/ANC/ and Inkatha, c.a. July 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.157, Report of the ANC, Joint Working Committee of COSATU/UDF (JWC) and NCLG, 7 August 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.159, Report on Peace Committee of UDF/COSATU and Inkatha Meeting, 8 August 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.160, Report on NCLG and an Inkatha delegation meeting, 13 August 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.167, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 17 September 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.1.172, Points arising out of meeting between Bishops Michael Nuttall, Lawrence Zulu and Dr MG Buthelezi, Re: Proposed meeting at the Bishopscourt, Cape Town, 23 November 1990.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.2, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 31 January 1991.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.2, Mission statement of the NCLG as discussed at the meeting, 31 January 1991.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.6, Dean Forbes and Bishop Nuttall to Chief Buthelezi and Mr Mandela, 8 March 1991.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.12, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 25 April 1991. See also short notes handwritten by Bishop Nuttall on copy of filed minutes.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.21, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 10 June 1991.         [ Links ]

DN, Minutes of NCLG and ANC meeting, 19 October 1992 (not indexed).         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.107, Mangosuthu Buthelezi, Chief Minister of KwaZulu and President of IFP, Greetings to the Bishops of the CPSA, 11 November 1992.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.111, Record of NCLG and ANC & IFP meetings, October -November 1992.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.114, The Diakonia Community Newsletter, December 1992.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.116, Bishop Michael Nuttall's sermon, Natal Peace Service, 13 December 1992.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.122, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 20 January 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.125, Minutes of NCLG and representatives of Northern Natal Church Leaders' meeting, 23 February 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.157, NCLG to Chief Buthelezi and Mr Mandela, 1 July 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.160, Minutes of NCLG Liaison Committee and representatives of the IFP meeting, 14 July 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.181, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 20 October 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.194, NCLG to Chief Buthelezi, Re: statement on elections, 24 November 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.195, Chief Buthelezi to Norman Hudson, Convenor of the NCLG, Re: response to statement on elections, 25 November 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.2.196, NCLG to Chief Minister Buthelezi, 2 December 1993.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.1, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 11 January 1994.         [ Links ]

DN, Michael Cassidy to Michael Nuttall, 1 March 1994 (not indexed).         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.10, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 14 February 1994.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.15, NCLG Prayer for Elections (not dated).         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.20, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 23 March 1994.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.33, Church leaders of KZN and AE, open invitation to the Jesus Peace Rally, KwaZulu-Natal, 17 April 1994.         [ Links ]

DN/DR/B/17.15.3.54, Minutes of NCLG meeting, 24 August 1994.         [ Links ]

• Lutheran Theological Institute, Pietermaritzburg (LTI)

W. Kistner Collections 1971A, Joint statement of the IFP and ANC, 29 January 1991.         [ Links ]

W. Kistner Collections, 3226A, A word of welcome to international mediators by Mangosuthu Buthelezi, President of IFP, 12 April 1994.         [ Links ]

• Bessie Head Library, Pietermaritzburg

Daily News Correspondent, "Mandela shows the friendly touch as he meets the Press", Daily News, 13 February 1990, 3.         [ Links ]

Reporter, "Long link with the Church", Daily News, 8 February 1990, 19.         [ Links ]

Reporter, "The President's opening address", Natal Witness, 3 February 1990, 3.         [ Links ]

Reporter, "Bishop's warning of long, hard road ahead", Daily News, 14 February 1990, 4.         [ Links ]

Hanna, Vic, "Acclaim for Mandela Speech", Daily News, 26 February 1990, 1.         [ Links ]

Books and articles

Aitchison, John 1993. Numbering the dead: the course and pattern of violence in the Natal Midlands: 1987-1989. Unpublished MA dissertation. Pietermaritzburg, University of Natal.         [ Links ]

Burton, John W 1996. Conflict resolution: its language and process. London: The Scarecrow Press.         [ Links ]

CPSA 1986. The enthronement charge of Archbishop Desmond Tutu and sermon of the Archbishop of Canterbury, 7 September.         [ Links ]

De Gruchy, John W 2005. The church struggle in South Africa. 25th anniversary edition, Minneapolis: Fortress.         [ Links ]

Denis, Philippe 2008. Men of the cloth. The Federal Theological Seminary of Southern Africa, Inkatha and the struggle against apartheid. Journal of Southern African Studies 34(2), June, 305-324.         [ Links ]

International Commission of Jurists 1990. Signposts to peace: an independent survey of the violence in Natal, South Africa. December.         [ Links ]

Institute of Contextual Theology 1986. The Kairos Document: the challenge to the church. Revised second edition. Braamfontein: Skotaville Publishers.         [ Links ]

Jeffrey, Anthea J 1997. The Natal story: sixteen years of conflict. Johannesburg: South African Institute of Race Relations.         [ Links ]

Johnston, A 1997. Politics and violence in KwaZulu-Natal, in Gutteridge, William F & Spence, John E (eds.), Violence in Southern Africa, 79-107. London: Frank Cass.         [ Links ]

Kentridge, Matthew 1990. An unofficial war: inside the conflict in Pietermaritzburg. Cape Town and Johannesburg: David Philip.         [ Links ]

Keys, Radley 1999. March 27th and 28th 1990: Edendale/Vulindlela Valley, Pietermaritzburg, in Levine, Lou (ed.), Faith in turmoil: the Seven Days War, 93-103. Pietermaritzburg: PACSA.         [ Links ]

Kraybill, Ronald S, Evans, Robert A & Evans, Alice F 2001. Peace skills: a manual for community mediators. San Francisco: A Wiley Company.         [ Links ]

Leviton, Sharon C & Greenstone, James L 1997. Elements of mediation. Pacific Grove: Books/Cole.         [ Links ]

Linscott, Graham 1994. Natal killing fields. Roots of the conflict in Natal: a selection of papers on violence in the colony and province presented at a workshop at the University of Natal on 25-26 October 1993, Pietermaritzburg: Department of Historical Studies, University of Natal, 81-89.         [ Links ]

Lyster, Richard 1999. Introduction, in Levine, Lou (ed.), Faith in turmoil: the Seven Days War, 12-14. Pietermaritzburg: PACSA.         [ Links ]

Nuttall, Michael 2000. Mediation efforts in turbulent times, Natalia 30, December, 24-30.         [ Links ]

Nuttall, Michael 2003. Number two to Tutu: a memoir. Pietermaritzburg: Cluster.         [ Links ]

Temkin, Ben 2003. Buthelezi: a biography. London: Frank Cass.         [ Links ]

Tutu, Desmond 1983. Hope and suffering: sermons and speeches of the Right Reverend Desmond Mpilo Tutu. Johannesburg: Skotaville.         [ Links ]

Waetjen, Thembisa & Maré, Gerhard 2008. Shaka's aeroplane: the take-off and landing of Inkatha, modern Zulu nationalism and royal politics, in Carton, Benedict, Laband, John & Sithole, Jabulani (eds.), Zulu identities: being Zulu, past and present, 352-362. Scottsville: University of KwaZulu-Natal Press.         [ Links ]

 

 

1 This article follows on, as part two, from a previous article by the same author. The first article focused on the period 1987 to early 1990 and this second article draws attention to the work of the Natal Church Leaders' Group in the years between 1990 and 1994. See Michael Mbona, "On embassy to Ulundi: the Natal Church Leaders' Group mediation attempts in war-torn Natal (1987-1990)", Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae 36, 1, (May 2010), 141-162.
2 Michael Mbona is a PhD student in the History of Christianity programme, School of Religion and Theology at the University of KwaZulu-Natal under the supervision of Professor Philippe Denis.