SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.49 número3Calvin in the intellectual heritage of the WestCalvin's ethics of socio-economic life índice de autoresíndice de assuntospesquisa de artigos
Home Pagelista alfabética de periódicos  

Serviços Personalizados

Artigo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • Em processo de indexaçãoCitado por Google
  • Em processo de indexaçãoSimilares em Google

Compartilhar


Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe

versão On-line ISSN 2224-7912
versão impressa ISSN 0041-4751

Tydskr. geesteswet. vol.49 no.3 Pretoria  2009

 

Johannes Calvyn (1509-1564) se mensbeskouing: 'n Christelik-filosofiese waardering

 

John Calvin's view of the human being: A Christian philosophical appraisal

 

 

BJ van der Walt

Skool vir Filosofie, Noordwes-Universiteit, Potchefstroom, Epos: hannah@intekom.co.za

 

 


OPSOMMING

Hierdie studie word aangebied ter herdenking van die geboorte van die hervormer, Johannes Calvyn, 500 jaar gelede (1509). Dit handel oor 'n belangrike aspek van sy denke, naamlik sy mensbeskouing volgens die finale uitgawe van sy Institusie (1559). Ter inleiding word iets vermeld van die voortgesette belangstelling in en relevansie van hierdie denker - ook in Suid-Afrika; 'n meer gebalanseerde evaluering van sy denke word voorgestel; die metode wat daarby gevolg word, word verduidelik. Daarna word die volgende fasette van Calvyn se antropologie bespreek: (1) die religieuse karakter van menswees; (2) sy onderskeid tussen siel en liggaam; (3) sy standpunt oor die onsterflikheid van die siel; (4) sy visie op die mens as beeld van God; (5) sy onderskeid tussen natuurlike en bonatuurlike gawes. Die slotgedeelte bevat 'n opsommende evaluering asook 'n les vir vandag.

Trefwoorde: Reformasie (16e eeuse), Johannes Calvyn (1509-1564), die Institusie (1559), Calvynnavorsing, Calvinisme (in Suid-Afrika), Grieks-Romeinse filosofie, Platonisme, Augustianisme, parsiële universalisme, Godskennis, religie, siel en liggaam, onsterflikheid (van die siel), kreasianisme, wêreldveragting, natuurlike en bonatuurlike beeld van God


ABSTRACT

This investigation is focused on an important aspect of Calvin's teachings, viz. his anthropology according to the final edition of his main systematic work, his Institutes (1559).
This contribution (to commemorate his birthday 500 years ago) is developed through the following main sections: The introduction briefly indicates the contemporary interest and continued relevance of Calvin - also for South Africans - even half a millennium after his birth. It further indicates the need to reflect anew on Calvin's anthropology. Then it draws attention to the fact that Calvin's intention was to be obedient to God and his Word alone (the religious direction of his thought), but that he did not always succeed in applying this intention in his structural analysis of the human being. He often employed pre-Christian philosophical ideas to explain his view of being human. Two different "lines" can therefore be detected in his anthropology. Lastly, the introduction explains the problem-historical method according to which Calvin's view of the human being will be analysed.
The rest of the essay focuses on the following aspects of Calvin's anthropology: (1) being human as being religious; (2) Calvin's structural analysis of the human being consisting of body and soul or spirit; (3) his idea of an immortal soul; (4) his view of man as the image of God; (5) his distinction in man/woman between a natural and supernatural image.
These various aspects of Calvin's viewpoint should be understood in the light of the following. Calvin's anthropology is determined by his dualistic ontology or view of reality, in which he distinguishes between God (the Transcendent) and creation (the non-transcendent part). He proposes a clearly dichotomist anthropology of body and soul/spirit as separate entities. According to him the soul is of divine origin. He can therefore be called a creatianist - God creates a soul for every new human person, and after death the soul returns to its Origin. Amongst the great variety of dichotomist anthropologies, Calvin's viewpoint can be characterised as semi-mystical. Semi-mysticism teaches that human beings are not completely non-transcendent (earthly) creatures, but also have a transcendent (divine) part, viz. their souls. Thus the borderline between the transcendent God and man is not perceived to be above but inside human beings. Amongst the different types of semi-mysticism, Calvin accepted a Platonising type - certain themes from Plato's philosophy are included and combined with other pre-Christian philosophical and biblical ideas in his view of the human person.
Concerning the different aspects of being human distinguished above (1 to 5), the results of this investigation can be summarised as follows:
 Calvin was not primarily interested in the human being himself/herself, independent from his/her relationship with God. Right at the beginning of his Institutes he emphasised the inseparable relationship between knowledge of God and the self. Religio or cultus Dei to him was also not confined to private devotional life or church attendance, but understood as all-encompassing service of God in all domains of life. The question, however, remains whether other aspects of his anthropology did not prevent him from working out this basic biblical idea consistently.
 According to Calvin it is a fact not to be debated that man/woman consists of two separate entities, viz. body and soul. The soul is an incorporeal substance which has been placed by God in the body in which it lives as if in a house which it manages. The body is also regarded as a prison of the soul resulting in contempt for earthly life and a longing for heaven. Death is regarded as a friend instead of as God's punishment. Such a viewpoint leads to many unsolvable problems, apart from the fact that it is to the author's mind in total disagreement with what the Word of God really reveals about the human being according to contemporary interpretations.
 Calvin furthermore regarded the soul as immortal and he provided a whole list of arguments (derived from both reason and the Bible) to prove this belief. What exactly he had in mind is not very clear. If he was saying that the soul is immortal in and of itself, he would have contradicted the biblical message that only God is by nature immortal and that the human being (not only the soul) will only receive immortality as a gift from God after his/her resurrection. Even if he (as some interpreters of his ideas like to argue) accepted this biblical viewpoint, the question remains why he spoke about the immortality of the soul only and not that of the human being.
 In line with his dualist ontology and dichotomist anthropology Calvin explained the biblical message that man is the image of God in an ontological instead of a relational way. Because of his divine part (the soul), the human being to a certain degree is similar to God. According to a (modified) macrocosmos-microcosmos theory human beings are "smaller gods". However, the Bible clearly teaches that not something in man (only the soul), but man was created in God's image. After the fall the integral human being has to be renewed according to Christ, the perfect image of God the Father. Human beings can again reflect His image when they obey his commandments.
Calvin's idea of the imago Dei is complicated by his distinction between a natural and a supernatural image. The natural image consists of the faculties of the soul, borrowed from Plato's and Aristotle's philosophy. The supernatural image is understood in biblical terms as righteousness and holiness. According to Calvin the supernatural image was lost at the fall, but the natural was merely corrupted because without reason and a will the human being would lose its human nature. This dichotomy in Calvin's doctrine of God's image cannot be accepted in the light of Scripture. It is, furthermore, closely connected with his distinction between earthly and heavenly affairs and could, therefore, cancel his basic religious motivation to live to the honour and glory of God in everything we do. However, it enabled Calvin to show his appreciation of all the natural gifts of non-Christians, including their philosophies.
As a summa summarum the following can be said: Calvin's thought once again clearly illustrated that no discipline - not even a biblical theology - can be practised without starting (deliberately or unintentionally) from deep philosophical presuppositions. We therefore do not blame Calvin because he employed philosophical ideas in constructing his anthropology. Philosophy as such is not dangerous to a Christian. This article argued against Calvin's use of pre-Christian ideas and, objected to the fact that he, furthermore, often did so in a much too uncritical way. But because in his time no integral Christian philosophy was available - as is the case today - our criticism should not be too harsh and one-sided. We should rather look for Calvin's own, unique contributions. A contemporary Reformational philosopher advised that the "real Calvin" is not met within the reiterations he made of views current amongst his contemporaries, but rather the new and non-conformist insights by which on crucial points he turned against the prevalent notions of the day.

Key concepts: Reformation (16th century), John Calvin (1509-1564), the Institutes (1559), Calvin research, Calvinism (in South Africa), Greek-Roman philosophy, Platonism, Augustinianism, partial universalism, knowledge of God, religion, soul and body, immortality (of soul), creatianism, world-flight, natural and supernatural image of God


 

 

Full text available only in PDF format.

 

 

BIBLIOGRAFIE

Babelotzky, G. 1977. Platonische Bilder und Gedankengänge in Calvins Lehre vom Menschen. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner Verlag.         [ Links ]

Battenhouse, R.W. 1948. The doctrine of man in Calvin and in Renaissance Platonism. Journal of the history of ideas, 9:447-471.         [ Links ]

Battles, F.J. & Hogo, A.M. 1969. Calvin's commentary on Seneca 's "De dementia". Leiden: Brill.         [ Links ]

Bril, K.A. 2005. Vollenhoven's Problem-historical method; introduction and explorations (Translated by Vunderink, R.W.) Sioux Center, Iowa: Dordt College Press.         [ Links ]

Bril, K.A. & Boonstra, P.J. 2000. D.H.Th. Vollenhoven: Schematische Kaarten, filosofische concepties in probleemhistorisch verband. Amstelveen: De Zaak Haes.         [ Links ]

Calvijn, J. 1931. Institutie of onderwijzing in de Christelijke godsdienst. 3 dele. (Vertaald door Sizoo, A.) Delft: Meinema.         [ Links ]

Calvijn, J. 1969. Psychopannychia (1534). Nederlandse vertaling in Stemmen van Geneve, nr. 8, Julie.         [ Links ]

Calvin, J. 1960. Institutes of the Christian Religion. (2 volumes.) (Translated by Battles, F.L. Ed. by McNeill, J.T.) (Library of Christian Classics, vol. 20 and 21.) Philadelphia: The Westminster Press.         [ Links ]

Calvini, J. 1967, 1968, 1962. Opera Selecta, vol. 3-5: Institutionis Christianae Religionis (1559). Ediderunt P. Barth & G. Niesel. München: Chr. Kaiser Verlag.         [ Links ]

Calvyn, J. 1967. Institusie van onderwys in die Christelike godsdiens. (Vertaal en verkort deur Duvenage, A.) Potchefstroom: Pro Rege Pers. (In 1978 herdruk deur NG Kerkboekhandel, Pretoria.         [ Links ]).

Calvyn, J. 1980a. Institusie. (Onderwysing in die Christelike Godsdiens). (Eerste uitgawe van 1536, vertaal deur Simpson, H.W.) Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds.         [ Links ]

Calvyn, J. 1980b. Calvyn vir vandag; dagstukke. (Saamgestel en vertaal deur Potgieter, F. J.M.). Kaapstad: Verenigde Protestantse Uitgewers.         [ Links ]

Calvyn, J. 1981. Kategismus. (Vertaal deur Simpson, H.W.) Potchefstroom: Potchefstroomse Teologiese Publikasies.         [ Links ]

Calvyn, J. 1984, 1986, 1988, 1992. Institusie van die Christelike Godsdiens. (4 dele.) (Vertaal deur Simpson, H.W.) Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds.         [ Links ]

Calvyn, J. 2008. Kommentaar op Romeine. (Vertaal deur S. Postma.) (Reeks Klassieke Tekste, nr. 1). Bloemfontein: IKRS & Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds.         [ Links ]

D'Assonville, V. 2009a. Calvynjaar 2009 - die aanloop vir 2009. Die Kerkblad, 112(3222):12-14, April.         [ Links ]

D'Assonville, V. 2009b. Calvyn - 500 jaar later. Woord en Daad, 48(407), herfs (verskyn binnekort).         [ Links ]

De Klerk, P. 1979-1995. Calvin bibliography. Calvin Theological Journal, 14:187-212 up to 30:419-447.         [ Links ]

De Koster, L.R. 1964. Living themes in the thought of John Calvin; a bibliographical study. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Univ. Microfilms.         [ Links ]

Den Hertog, W.E. 1937. De anthropologie van Calvijn. Vox Theologica, 9:137-148.         [ Links ]

Fowler, S. 1991. A Christian voice among students and scholars. Potchefstroom: Institute for Reformational Studies.         [ Links ]

Fowler, S. 2004. On being human; towards a biblical understanding. Melbourne: Amani Educational Services.         [ Links ]

Hugo, A.M. 1957. Calvijn en Seneca; een inleidende studie van Calvijn's Commentaar op Seneca "De Clementia", anno 1532. Groningen: Wolters.         [ Links ]

Kempff, D. 1975. A bibliography of Calviniana: 1959-1974. Potchefstroom: Institute for the Advancement of Calvinism.         [ Links ]

Klapwijk, J. 1972. Calvijn over de filosofie. Correspondentiebladen van de Vereniging voor Calvinistische Wijsbegeerte, 36:13-20. Maart.         [ Links ]

Klapwijk, J. 1973. Calvin and Neo-Calvinism on non-Christian philosophy. Philosophia Reformata, 38:43-71.         [ Links ]

Klapwijk, J. 1991. John Calvin (1509-1564). In Klapwijk, J., Griffioen, S., Groenewoud, G. (eds). Bringing to captivity every thought; capita selecta in the history of Christian evaluations of non-Christian philosophy. Lanham: Univ. Press of America. pp. 123-142.         [ Links ]

Lief, J. 2009. Is Neo-Calvinism Calvinist? A Neo-Calvinist engagement with Calvin's "two kingdoms" doctrine. Pro Rege, 37(3):1-12.         [ Links ]

Nuovo, V.L. 1964. Calvin's theology; a study of its sources in classical antiquity. Ann Arbor, Michigan: University Microfilms.         [ Links ]

Oberman, H.A. 1994. Initii Calvini; the matrix of Calvin's Reformation. In Neuzer, W.H. (ed.). Calvinus sacra Scripturae Professor. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans. pp. 113-154.         [ Links ]

Partee, C. 1977. Calvin and classical philosophy. Leiden: E.J. Brill.         [ Links ]

Schreiner, S.E. 1991. The theater of His glory; nature and natural order in the thought of John Calvin. Durham, North Carolina: The Labyrinth Press.         [ Links ]

Schroten, H. 1956. De anthropologie van Calvijn. In Waarheid, wijsheid en leven. Kampen: Kok, pp. 47-62.         [ Links ]

Snyman, W.J. 1961. Lewe, dood en onsterflikheid in die Nuwe Testament. Koers, 28(10): 417-430.         [ Links ]

Spykman, G.J. 1992. Reformational theology; a new paradigm for doing dogmatics. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

Stellingwerff, J. 1965. Oorsprong en toekomst van de creatieve mens. Amsterdam: Buijten & Schipperheijn.         [ Links ]

Talma, A.S.E. 1882. De antropologie van Calvijn. Utrecht: Breijer.         [ Links ]

Van der Merwe, N.T. 1982. Calvin, Augustine and Platonism. In Van der Walt, B.J. (ed.). Calvinus reformator; his contribution to theology, church and society. Potchefstroom: Institute for Reformational Studies. pp. 69-84.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 1974. Die Natuurlike Teologie met besondere aandag aan die visie daarop by Thomas van Aquino, Johannes Calvyn en die "Synopsis Purioris Theologiae"; 'n wysgerige ondersoek. Ongepubliseerde D.Phil-proefskrif, Potchefstroom: PU vir CHO.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 1977. Onskriftuurlike trekke in die mensbeskouing van Calvyn. Tydskrif vir Christelike wetenskap, 13:172-189.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 1979. From Noyon to Geneva; a pilgrimage in the steps of John Calvin. Potchefstroom: Institute for the Advancement of Calvinism.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 1980a. Van Noyon na Genève; reisindrukke van 'n Calvynpelgrim. Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds        [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (red.). 1980b. Die inslag van die Calvinisme in Suid-Afrika, deel 1: histories en prinsipieel. Potchefstroom: Instituut vir die Bevordering van die Calvinisme.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (red.). 1980c. Die inslag van die Calvinisme in Suid-Afrika; deel 2: godsdienstig en teologies. Potchefstroom: Instituut vir die Bevordering van die Calvinisme.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (red.). 1980d. Die inslag van die Calvinisme in Suid-Afrika; deel 3: wetenskaplik en opvoedkundig. Potchefstroom: Instituut vir die Bevordering van die Calvinisme.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (red.). 1980e. Die inslag van die Calvinisme in Suid-Afrika; deel 4: maatskaplik en staatkundig. Potchefstroom: Instituut vir die Bevordering van die Calvinisme.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 2008a. Renaissance and Reformation: contemporaries but not allies. In Van der Walt, B.J. Anatomy of reformation. Potchefstroom: The Institute for Contemporary Christianity in Africa, pp. 201-208.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 2008b. The intellectual décor of the Reformation with special reference to Calvin. In Van der Walt, B.J. Anatomy of Reformation. Potchefstroom: The Institute for Comtemporary Christianity in Africa, pp. 209-256.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 2008c. The place of theology in relationship philosophy. In Van der Walt, B.J. Transformed by the renewing of your mind. Potchefstroom: The Institute for Contemporary Christianity, pp. 158-165.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. 2009. At home in God's world: a transforming paradigm for being human and for social involvement. Potchefstroom: The Institute for Contemporary Christianity in Africa.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (ed.). 1982. Calvinus Reformator; his contribution to theology, church and society. Potchefstroom: Institute for Reformational Studies.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, B.J. (ed.). 1986. John Calvin's "Insitutes", his "opus magnum". Potchefstroom: Institute for Reformational Studies.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, J. 1981. Calvyn; 'n jeugroman. Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds.         [ Links ]

Van der walt, J. 1985. Calvin and his times. Potchefstroom: Institute for Reformational Studies.         [ Links ]

Van der Walt, J. 2007. The dawn of a new light; lifestory of John Calvin. Potchefstroom: Calvyn Jubileumboekefonds.         [ Links ]

Van Niekerk, E.J. & Hayes, H.J. (reds.). 2002. Reformerend die millennium in; ons Calvinistiese erfenis en roeping. Bloemfontein: Vereniging vir Christelike Hoër Onderwys.         [ Links ]

Vollenhoven, D.H.Th. 1992. Vollenhoven als wijsgeer; inleidingen en teksten. (Reds. Tol, A en Bril, K.A.). Amsterdam: Buijten & Schipperheijn.         [ Links ]

Vollenhoven, D.H.Th. 2005a. De probleem-historische methode en de geschiedenis van de Wijsbegeerte. (Red. Bril, K.A.). Amstelveen: De Zaak Haes.         [ Links ]

Vollenhoven, D.H.Th. 2005b The problem-historical method and the history of philosophy. (Ed. Bril, K.A., Translated by De Kievit, J., Francke, S., Friesen, G. & Sweetman, R.) Amstelveen: De Zaak Haes.         [ Links ]

Vollenhoven, D.H.Th. 2005c. Isagôgè philosophiae; introduction to philosophy. (Eds Kok, J.H; & Tol, A.) Sioux Center, Iowa: Dordt College Press.         [ Links ]

Vollenhoven, D.H.Th. 2005d. Wijsgerig Woordenboek. Amstelveen: De Zaak Haes.         [ Links ]

Wendel, F. 1963. Calvin; the origins and development of his religious thought. London: Collins, Sons & Co.         [ Links ]

Wolters, A.M. 1985. Creation regained. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans.         [ Links ]

Zuidema, S.U. 1971. Common grace and Christian action in Abraham Kuyper. In Zuidema, S.U. Communication and confrontation; a philosophical appraisal and critique of modern society and contemporary thought. Assen: Van Gorcum & Kampen: Kok, pp. 52-105.         [ Links ]

 

 

1 "Tota fere sapientiae nostrae summa, quae vera demum ac solida sapientia censeri debeat, duabus partibus constat, Dei cognitione et nostri. Caeterum quum multis inter se vinculis connexae sint, utra tamen alteram praecedat, et ex se pariat, non facile est discernere. Nam primo, se nemo aspicere potest quin ad Dei in quo vivit et movetur, intuitum sensus suos protinus convertat: quia minime obscurum est, dotes quibus pollemus, nequaquam a nobis esse; imo ne id quidem ipsum quod sumus, aliud esse quam in uno Deo subsistentiam." (I, 1, 1.)
2 "Rursum, hominem in puram sui notitiam nunquam pervenire constat nisi prius Dei faciem sit contemplatus, atque ex illius intuitu ad seipsum inspiciendum descendat." (I, 1, 2.).
3 "Ac quamvis primaria sedes Divinae imaginis fuerit in mente et corde, vel in anima eiusque potentiis: nulla tamen pars fuit etiam usque ad corpus, in qua non scintillae aliquae micarent. Certum est in singulis etiam mundi partibus fulgere lineamenta quaedam gloriae Dei: unde colligere licet, ubi in homine locatur eius imago, tacitam subesse antithesin quae hominem supra alias omnes creaturas extollat, et quasi separet a vulgo" (I, 15, 3.).

 

 

Bennie van der Walt studeer aan die (destydse) Potchefstroomse Universiteit vir CHO en die Vrije Universiteit van Amsterdam en behaal die grade Th.B. en D.Phil. (Filosofie). Vanaf 1970 tot 1974 was hy senior lektor in Filosofie aan die Universiteit van Fort Hare, vanaf 1975 tot 1999 direkteur van die Instituut vir die Bevordering van die Calvinisme, later herdoop tot die Instituut vir Reformatoriese Studie, en (vanaf 1980) ook professor in Filosofie. Sedert sy emeritaat (1999) is hy navorsingsgenoot - tans by die Skool vir Filosofie op die Potchefstroomkampus van die Noordwes-Universiteit. Deesdae skryf hy heelwat artikels vir geakkrediteerde tydskrifte in Afrikaans en publiseer ook gereeld monografieë in Engels. Van sy geskrifte is ook vertaal in onder andere Hongaars, Nederlands, Koreaans, Spaans, Portugees, Xhosa en Tswana. Hy het twee eregrade van instellings in Korea en Hongarye ontvang.

Bennie van der Walt studied at the Potchefstroom University for Christian Higher Education and at the Free University of Amsterdam and obtained the Th.B.(Theology) and D.Phil. (Philosophy) degrees. From 1970 to 1974 he was senior lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Fort Hare; from 1975 to 1999 he was director of the Institute for Reformational Studies and also (from 1980) professor in Philosophy at the Potchefstroom University for Christian Higher Education. After his retirement (1999) he was appointed as research fellow of the School of Philosophy at the North-West University (Potchefstroom Campus). He has written many books and articles in refereed journals. Some of his writings were translated into the English, Dutch, Hungarian, Korean, Spanish, Portuguese, Xhosa and Tswana languages. He received two honorary degrees from institutions in Korea and Hungary.

Creative Commons License Todo o conteúdo deste periódico, exceto onde está identificado, está licenciado sob uma Licença Creative Commons