On-line version ISSN 2224-7912
Tydskr. geesteswet. vol.49 n.2 Pretoria 2009
An approach to financial vulnerability reduction: Financial literacy education within a social development paradigm
Departement Maatskaplike Werk, Universiteit van Stellenbosch firstname.lastname@example.org
'n Beduidende aantal mense in Suid-Afrika, wat in die maatskaplike welsynsisteem geakkom-modeer word, toon gebrekkige finansiële begrip en is derhalwe finansieel kwesbaar. 'n Relevante benadering om mense se finansiële kwesbaarheid te reduseer binne die maatskaplike ontwikkelingsparadigma kan dus 'n bydrae tot die land se teen-armoede-strategie lewer en motiveer die doel van hierdie artikel, naamlik om 'n benadering tot finansiële kwesbaarheids-reduksie binne 'n maatskaplike ontwikkelingsparadigma te konstrueer. Die doel van die artikel word bereik deur die Suid-Afrikaanse maatskaplike ontwikkelingsparadigma te kontekstualiseer, waarna finansiële kwesbaarheid en finansiële geletterdheidsopvoeding binne hierdie konteks verken, beskryf en as praktykrealiteit ondersoek word deur middel van 'n instrumentele kwalitatiewe gevallestudie, bestaande uit tien deelnemers wat by 'n gevestigde nie-regeringsorganisasie (NRO) werksaam is. As uitkoms word kernelemente van finansiële geletterdheidsopvoeding as benadering vir finansiële kwesbaarheidsreduksie binne die plaaslike maatskaplike ontwikkelingsparadigma gekonstrueer. Binne hierdie paradigma is finansiële geletterdheidsopvoeding 'n mikropraktykbenadering wat volgens volwasseneonderrigbeginsels op definitiewe uitgangspunte en perspektiewe gegrond is. Hierdie mikropraktykbenadering behels die bewusmaking en deurlopende, lewenslange aanleer van 'n stel multi-dimensionele persoonsgesentreerde lewensvaardighede. Finansiële geletterdheidsopvoeding verwys ook na situasie-relevante kompetensies, wat bestaan uit spesifieke kennis, waardes en vaardighede binne inheemse kulturele verband en is gefokus op mense se vermoë om hulle beskikbare geld te bestuur. Hierdie benadering kan die grondslag vir suksesvolle inkomstegenereringsprojekte lê, kan as onderbou vir mense se migrasie na die hoofstroomekonomie dien en kan ook na ander lewensterreine getransponeer word. Sodoende word ekonomiese en menslike ontwikkeling binne 'n maatskaplike intervensiekonteks geïntegreer en is dit binne bereik van maatskaplike ontwikkelingspraktisyns om te fasiliteer.
Trefwoorde: Finansiële kwesbaarheid, armoede, finansiële geletterdheid, finansiële geletterdheidsopvoeding, intervensieprogramme, praktykbenadering, maatskaplike ontwikkelingsparadigma, welsynsbeleid, maatskaplike ontwikkelingspraktisyn, maatskaplike werk, nie-regeringsorganisasie, gevallestudie, inkomstegenerering, maatskaplike bestaansbeveiliging, ekonomiese en menslike ontwikkeling
A significant number of people in South Africa who are accommodated within the social welfare system, display a lack of understanding of financial matters and are therefore financially vulnerable. In South Africa, social welfare policy initiatives are directed by the White Paper for Social Welfare and are primarily focussed on the socio-economic needs of all South Africans, specifically those of the previously disadvantaged and poor people of the country. This White Paper which supplies a macro-policy framework for poverty alleviation, is based on social development theories, combining social and economic objectives. Practitioners of social development however, deal with financially vulnerable people on a daily basis, and within the social development paradigm, must attempt to set into operation the development goals on the micro-practice level. This matter informs the objective of this article, namely to construct an approach to financial vulnerability reduction within a social development paradigm. This could make a contribution to the country's strategy against poverty.
In this article the South African social development paradigm will be placed in its proper context, after which financial vulnerability and financial literacy education will be explored and described and also examined as a practice reality by means of an instrumental qualitative case study. Participants in the case study consisted of ten registered social workers employed at an established non-government organisation (NGO). Purposive non-probability sampling was used to select the participants, as these social development practitioners could offer expert opinions on the subject. This particular NGO delivers social development services in several provinces and like other NGOs should adhere to the financial policy of the Department of Social Development.
The aim of the case study was to explore how development practitioners perceive and experience the financial vulnerability of their service users (clients) within a social development paradigm as practice reality in South Africa. This goal was attained through the explorative and descriptive nature of the study. Semi-structured interviews were used as research instrument in order to elicit comments most effectively from the participants. Themes arising from the comments were processed and presented in synthesised form in the article, based on and integrated with the literature study, to ensure validity through triangulation. The case study was thus directed towards reaching the goal as set out in the article, as the findings are to be construed as key elements of financial literacy education as an approach to reduce financial vulnerability within the local social development paradigm.
The findings show that financial vulnerability reduction by means of financial literacy education is an appropriate micro-practice approach by social development practitioners to attain social development goals within the context of the organisation. This approach therefore provides social development practitioners with a definite, concrete role within the social development paradigm, as they are structurally positioned to deliver financial education to financially vulnerable service users. This can lay the foundation for successful income-generating projects to be implemented. This approach means that income-generating projects are initially of secondary importance, as the development practitioners are primarily focussed on enhancing financial literacy as a life skill in the community. Traditionally this constitutes a major part of the intervention by social service professionals.
The fundamental premise of this approach is that people's financial vulnerability could be reduced, enabling them to manage looming financial risks. Within the context of this study, financially vulnerable people refer to those users of social welfare services who have little or no continuous financial support, and do not have at their disposal the necessary resources to survive in times of financial distress. Financial vulnerability is viewed here not only from a monetary perspective, but also in terms of people's limited capabilities. People are rendered vulnerable when they are unable to manage their money, which implies a lack of financial literacy, and usually manifests in unmanageable debt. Financially illiterate people are therefore in dire need of a set of indispensable life skills to survive in a globalising environment. These life skills are presented as part of an integrated generic social intervention process, implemented on individual, group and community level through financial literacy education.
Within a social development paradigm, financial literacy education is thus a micro-practice approach based on definite points of departure and perspectives in accordance with adult education principles. This education embraces the recognition and continuous, life-long learning of a set of multi-dimensional situation-relevant person-centred life skills within an indigenous cultural context, and is focussed on people's ability to manage their available funds. Partnerships are established between development practitioners and financial institutions, to serve as intervention resource for the presentation of financial literacy programmes. Development practitioners act as a bridge for dialogue between education programmes and vulnerable people and also ensure that financial literacy education programmes assume an appropriate position on a continuum of product marketing and general life skills.
Financial education programmes aim to be preventative. The skills of financially vulnerable people are developed towards effective decision-making and having informed opinions about the use and management of money. Accordingly, and with due regard to the specific needs of financially vulnerable people, the content of education programmes is focussed on competencies relating to knowledge, values and skills in respect of financial concepts, financial self-discipline and how to avoid financial exploitation and risks. Acquisition of these values, knowledge and skills, results in a reduction in financial vulnerability, enabling people to participate with confidence in the mainstream economy. This outcome could pave the way for further programmes aimed at income generation, serve as basis for people's migration to the mainstream economy and could be reciprocally transposed to other life spheres. In this way economic and human development are integrated within a social intervention context and placed within reach of social development practitioners to facilitate. Role players should take cognizance of this.
Key concepts: Financial vulnerability, poverty, financial literacy, financial literacy education, intervention programmes, practice approach, social development paradigm, welfare policy, social development practitioner, social work, non government organisation, case study, income generation, social security, economic and human development
Full text available only in PDF format.
Alarcon, D., Griffith-Jones, S. & Ocampo, J.A. 2009. How does the financial crisis affect developing countries? International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, April (81). [ Links ]
Bell, E. & Lerman, R.I. 2005. Can financial literacy enhance asset building? Washington DC: The Urban Institute. [ Links ]
Bloom, B.S. (ed.). 1956. Taxonomy of educational objectives, the classification of educational goals. New York: McKey. [ Links ]
Braunstein, S. & Welch, C. 2002. Financial literacy: An overview of practice, research, and policy. Federal Reserve Bulletin, November: 445-457. [ Links ]
Buys, F. 2005. Belastingstelsel verarm werkendes. Rapport, 17 Julie. [ Links ]
Buys, F. 2007. Ja vir 'n gelyke verdeling van armoede. Die Burger, 25 Augustus. [ Links ]
Citigroup. 2007. Financial education curriculum, http://financialeducation.citigroup.com/citigroup/financialeducation/curriculum/adults.htm [28 April 2007]. [ Links ]
Clancy, M., Grinstein-Weiss, M. & Schreiner, M. 2001. Financial education and savings outcomes in individual development accounts. Center for Social Development, Working Paper 01-2. St. Louis: Washington University. [ Links ]
Cohen, M., Stach, K. & McGuinnes, E. 2004. Financial education: A win-win for clients and MFIs. Washington DC: Microfinance Opportunities. [ Links ]
Collins, D. 2007. Focus note: Styles and profiles, investigating the financial lives of the poor. The connection between livelihoods and financial portfolios of the poor, http://www.financialdiaries.com [6 November 2007]. [ Links ]
Creswell, J.W. 1998. Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions. Thousand Oaks: Sage. [ Links ]
Delport, C.S.L. & Fouché, C.B. 2005. The qualitative research report. In De Vos, A.S. (ed.). Research at grass roots. A primer for the caring professions. Pretoria: Van Schaik, pp. 350-354. [ Links ]
Department of Social Development. 2003. Strategic plan of the Department of Social Development: 2003/4-2005/6. Pretoria: Government Printers. [ Links ]
Department of Social Development. 2005. Policy on the financial awards to service providers. Pretoria: Government Printers. [ Links ]
Department of Social Development. 2006. Integrated service delivery model towards improved social services. Pretoria: Government Printers. [ Links ]
Engelbrecht, L.K. 2006. Plumbing the brain drain of South African social workers migrating to the UK: Challenges for social service providers. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 42(2): 127-146. [ Links ]
Finmark Trust. 2004. Financial literacy scoping study and strategy project. Woodmead: ECI Africa. [ Links ]
Finmark Trust. 2007. Access to savings products in the low income market. Johannesburg: South Africa Savings Institute. [ Links ]
Fouché, C.B. 2005. Qualitative research designs. In De Vos, A.S. (ed.). Research at grass roots. A primer for the caring professions. Pretoria: Van Schaik, pp. 267-273. [ Links ]
Friedman, P. 2005. Providing and funding financial literacy programs for low-income adults and youth. Washington DC: The Finance Project. [ Links ]
Garman, E.T., Kim, J., Kratzer, C.Y., Brunson, B.H. & Joo, S. 1999. Workplace financial education improves personal financial wellness. Columbus: Association for Financial Counseling and Planning Education. [ Links ]
Gochros, H. 2005. Interviewing. In Grinnell, R.M & Unrau, Y.A. (eds). Social work research and evaluation. Quantitative and qualitative approaches. 7th ed. Oxford: University Press, pp. 246-269. [ Links ]
Goodwin-Groen, R.P & Kelly-Louw, M. 2006. The National Credit Act and its regulations in the context of access to finance in South Africa. Marshalltown: Finmark Trust. [ Links ]
Gray, M. 2006. The progress of social development in South Africa. International Journal for Social Welfare, 15 (Suppl. 1): 53-64. [ Links ]
Grinnell, R.M., Unrau,Y.A. & Williams, M. 2005. Scientific inquiry and social work. In Grinnell, R.M & Unrau, Y.A. (eds). Social work research and evaluation. Quantitative and qualitative approaches. 7th ed. Oxford: University Press. 4-21. [ Links ]
Hare, I. 2004. Defining social work for the 21st century. The International Federation of Social Workers' revised definition of social work. International Social Work, 3(47): 406-424. [ Links ]
Heney, J. 2000. Enhancing farmers' financial management skills. Agricultural Finance Revisited, no. 6: 1-86. [ Links ]
INSOL International. 2001. Consumer debt report: Report of findings and recommendations. London: International Federation of Insolvency Professionals. [ Links ]
Jacob, K., Hudson, S. & Bush, M. 2000. Tools for survival: An analysis of financial literacy programs for lower-income families. Chicago: Woodstock Institute. [ Links ]
Landman, J.P. 2004. Ecumenical Foundation of Southern Africa. Breaking the grip of poverty in South Africa, 2004-2014. Current trends, issues, and policy options, https://boepersonal.nedsecure.co.za/library/JPEFSA%20REPORT.PDF [5/8/2007]. [ Links ]
Link, P., Vawser, S., Downes, S. & Chant, G. 2004. Summary presentation: Research on financial exclusion in Australia. Victoria, Australia: ANZ, Chant Link & Associates. [ Links ]
Lombard, A. & Du Preez, J. 2003. Overcoming the challenges of building partnerships in social development. [ Links ]
Paper delivered at the Social Development Conference, 5 June 2003. Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University. [ Links ]
Lombard, A. 2003. Entrepreneurship in Africa: Social work challenges for human, social and economic development. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 39(3): 224-239. [ Links ]
Lusardi, A., & Mitchell, O.S. 2006. Financial literacy and retirement preparedness: Evidence and implications for financial education programs. Michigan Retirement Research Center, Working Paper 2006-144. Michigan: University of Michigan. [ Links ]
Marshall, C. & Rossman, G.B. 1999. Designing qualitative research. 3rd ed. London: Sage. [ Links ]
Mavrinac, S. & Ping, C.W. 2004. Financial education of women in Asia Pacific: An INSEAD working paper. Singapore: INSEAD Campus. [ Links ]
Midgley, J. 1995. Social development. The developmental perspective in social welfare. London: SAGE Publications. [ Links ]
Miley, K.K., O'Melia, M. & Du Bois, B. 2001. Generalist social work practice. An empowering approach. Boston: Allyn and Bacon. [ Links ]
Ministry for Welfare and Population Development. 1997. White Paper for Social Welfare. Notice 1108 of 1997. Government Gazette, 386 (18166). Pretoria, 8 August. [ Links ]
Mittner, M. 2007. Skuld groei steeds te snel. Min hoop dat 8ste rentekoersverhoging gekeer word. Sake 24, 30 Oktober. [ Links ]
Nash, J., Jenkinson, A., Vayro, A. & Sandlant, R. 2005. Understanding personal debt and financial difficulty in Australia. Melbourne: ANZ & ACNielson. [ Links ]
Patel, L. 2005. Social welfare and social development in South Africa. Southern Africa: Oxford University Press. [ Links ]
Rand, D. 2004. Financial education and asset building programs for welfare recipients and low income workers: The Illinois experience. Washington DC: The Brookings Institution, Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy. [ Links ]
Robinson, L. 2002 (ed.). Guide to financial literacy resources. San Francisco: Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Community Affairs Unit. [ Links ]
RSA. 1994. White Paper on Reconstruction and Development. Notice No. 1954. Government Gazette Vol. 353, No. 16085. Pretoria: Government Printer. [ Links ]
RSA. 2005. Nasionale Kredietwet, Wet 34. Staatsdrukker, nr. 28619 van 15 Maart 2006, vol. 489. [ Links ]
RSA. 2006. Nasionale Kredietregulasies. Staatsdrukker, nr. 28864 van 31 Mei 2006, vol.491, Regulasie 8477, R489. [ Links ]
Sandlant, R., Harris, A. & Barker, N. 2005. AZN survey of adultfinancial literacy in Australia. Melbourne: AZN & ACNielson. [ Links ]
Schagen, S. 1997. The evaluation of NatWest Face 2 Face With Finance. London: National Foundation for Education Research. [ Links ]
Schutt, R.K. 2005. Sampling. In Grinnell, R.M & Unrau, Y.A. (eds). Social work research and evaluation. Quantitative and qualitative approaches. 7th ed. Oxford: University Press, pp. 150-169. [ Links ]
Sieppert, J.D., McMurty, S.L. & McClelland, R.W. 2005. In Grinnell, R.M & Unrau, Y.A. (eds.) Social work research and evaluation. Quantitative and qualitative approaches. 7th ed. Oxford: University Press, pp. 316-328. [ Links ]
Taylor Committee. 2002. Transforming the present - Protecting the Future. Draft consolidated report of the Committee of Inquiry into a comprehensive system of social security for South Africa. Pretoria: Department of Social Development. [ Links ]
Ueckermann, H. 2007. Skole moet jonges leer oor geld. Loopbane 24, 4 November. [ Links ]
US Department of Labour, 2001. Dollars & sense: Implementing financial education in a one-stop setting. Washington DC: Office of Adult Services, Division of Welfare-to-Work. [ Links ]
Van Eeden, E.S., Ryke, E.H. & De Necker, I.C.M. 2000. The welfare function of the South African Government before and after apartheid. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 36(1): 1-24. [ Links ]
Wilensky, H.L. & Lebeaux, C.N. 1965. Industrial Society and Social Welfare. New York: The Free Press. [ Links ]
1 Vergelyk Finmark Trust 2004; INSOL International 2001; Link, Vawser, Downes & Chant 2004; Rand 2004; Robinson 2002.
2 Vergelyk Finmark Trust 2004; Nash, Jenkinson, Vayro & Sandlant 2005; Sandlant, Harris & Barker 2005.
3 Vergelyk Finmark Trust 2004; Nash et al. 2005; Rand 2004; Sandlant et al. 2005.
4 Vergelyk Bell & Lerman 2005; Jacob et al. 2000; Sandlant et al. 2005.
5 Vergelyk Cohen et al. 2004; Finmark Trust 2004; Mavrinac & Ping 2004.
6 Vergelyk onder meer Clancy et al. 2001; Cohen et al. 2004; Finmark Trust 2004; Goodwin-Groen & Kelly-Louw 2006; INSOL International 2001; Jacob et al. 2000; Lusardi & Mitchell 2006; Mavrinac & Ping 2004; Nash et al. 2005; Rand 2004; Robinson 2002; Sandlant et al. 2005; Schagen 1997; US Department of Labour 2001.
7 Vergelyk Cohen et al. 2004; Nash et al. 2005; Rand 2004; Sandlant et al. 2005; US Department of Labour 2001.
Dr Lambert Engelbrecht is 'n senior lektor aan die Departement Maatskaplike Werk van die Universiteit van Stellenbosch. Hy beskik oor uitgebreide praktykervaring as maatskaplike werker en gemeenskapsontwikkelaar in kwesbare gemeen-skappe. Sy belangstellingsvelde is maatskaplike-werkbestuur en -supervisie, sowel as armoedeverligtingstrategieë in maatskaplikewerkdiens-lewering. Hy integreer akademiese onderrig, sy navorsingsfunksie en gemeenskapsinteraksie in sy betrokkenheid by die bestuur van 'n gevestigde nie-regeringsorganisasie en by die supervisie van maatskaplike werkers. Hieruit spruit sy navorsing op die terrein van finansiële en ekonomiese geletterdheidsopvoeding van kwesbare mense. Verskeie artikels oor hierdie onderwerp is reeds deur hom in nasionale en internasionale vaktyd-skrifte gepubliseer. Hy lewer ook gereeld referate by etlike nasionale en internasionale vakkonferensies en het ook reeds verskeie kere as besoekende genoot by buitelandse opleidings-instansies vir maatskaplike werk opgetree.
Dr Lambert Engelbrecht is a senior lecturer in the Department of Social Work at the University of Stellenbosch. He has extensive experience as a social work practitioner and community developer in vulnerable communities. His interests lie in the fields of social work management and supervision, as well as strategies for poverty alleviation in social work service delivery. His role as lecturer, his engagement in research and interaction with the community find common purpose in his involvement in the management of an established non-governmental organisation and the supervision of social workers. From this stems his research into the financial and economic literacy education of vulnerable people. Several of his articles on this subject have been published in national and international professional journals. He regularly participates as a speaker at national and international conferences and has also acted as visiting fellow at international training institutes for social workers.