versión impresa ISSN 0030-2465
Onderstepoort j. vet. res. vol.79 no.1 Cape Town 2012
Felix NchuI; Solomon R. MaganoII; Jacobus N. EloffIII
IDepartment of Horticultural Science, Cape Peninsula University of Technology, South Africa
IIDepartment of Life and Consumer Sciences, University of South Africa, South Africa
IIIDepartment of Paraclinical Sciences, University of Pretoria, South Africa
In this study we examined the anti-tick properties of the essential oil of Tagetes minuta L. (Asteraceae: Asterales) against Hyalomma rufipes ticks. We obtained the essential oil of T. minuta by hydro-distillation of a combination of fresh flowers, leaves and soft stems, and analysed these by using gas chromatography (GC) and gas chromatography-linked mass spectrometry (GC-MS). The oil had a high percentage of monoterpenes and the major compounds identified were cis-ocimene (28.5%), beta-ocimene (16.83%) and 3-methyl-2-(2-methyl-2-butenyl)-furan (11.94%). Hyalomma rufipes adults displayed a significant (P < 0.05) dose repellent response to the essential oil of T. minuta. Probit analysis indicated a repellent EC50 of T. minuta essential oil for male ticks to be 0.072 mL/mL (CI 0.053 mL/mL to 0.086 mL/mL) and 0.070 mL/mL (CI 0.052 mL/mL to 0.084 mL/mL) for female ticks. There were no significant differences in repellent responses between male and female ticks. The oil also significantly (P < 0.05) delayed moulting of 60% of H. rufipes engorged nymphs. These results suggest that T. minuta may be a potential source of anti-tick agents.
The ability of ticks to transmit pathogens to livestock and their direct effect on the health and condition of animals has resulted in great economic losses in various parts of the world. McCosker (1979) estimated the global costs of control and productivity losses as $7000 million annually ($7/head/annum). In a recent study carried out in Tanzania, it was estimated that the total annual national loss as a consequence of tick-borne diseases was $364 million with a mortality of 1.3 million cattle (Kivaria 2006).
The current methods of tick control rely heavily on chemical acaricides and repellents. These chemicals have numerous detrimental effects, including environmental pollution (Bhattacarya, Sarkar & Mukherjee 2003) and acaricide resistance (Li et al. 2003), promoting the search for novel compounds from alternative sources such as plants. Plants contain secondary metabolites that are frequently stored in specialised tissues, and which may have biological or repellent properties when extracted (Evans 1989). Some of the plants traditionally used in Africa, for example, neem (Azadirachta indica) and Gynandropsis gynandra respectively, have effective acaricidal and tick repellent activity (Abdel-Shafy & Zayeb 2002; Lwande et al. 1999). In this regard, undiluted neem oil deterred larval and nymphal attachment, inhibited feeding (90% - 100%), reduced fecundity (30% - 45%) and egg hatchability (47% - 55%), decreased larval (22% - 93%) and nymphal (98%) moult of some ixodid ticks (Kaaya & Saxena 1998). Oil extracted from leaves of the tropical shrub Ocimum suave, repel and kill all stages of the tick Rhipicephalus appendiculatus (Mwangi et al. 1995). It has been known for many years that essential oil of Tagetes minuta has both repellent and growth inhibitory properties against insect pests (Jacobson 1983). Tagetes minuta also has the potential to control ticks (Moyo et al. 2009; Wanzala 2009). No experimental evidence, however, on the effects of T. minuta against Hyalomma rufipes has been found in the literature. In South Africa, T. minuta (also known as kakhi bush or mexican marigold) grows as a weed on maize farms, at roadsides and in gardens. The aim of this study was to evaluate the in vitro repellent and growth inhibitory bioactivities of T. minuta essential oil on H. rufipes adults. This tick species is widely distributed in Africa and is capable of transmitting disease-causing pathogens, to people and livestock, such as Crimean-Congo haemorrhagic fever virus and Babesia species, respectively (Gray & De Vos 1981; Walker et al. 2003).
Materials and methods
Hyalomma rufipes used in this study were bred on Himalayan rabbits at the Animal Production unit of the Department of Biology, University of Limpopo (MEDUNSA Campus). For rabbit infestation, ticks were placed in cotton bags attached to the back of the host. The hosts were shaved on their backs prior to infestation to facilitate attachment (Magano, Els & Chown 2000).
Plant material and extract preparation
Fresh leaves, branches and flowers of T. minuta were collected in April 2004 from a nursery and a maize field managed by the Department of Plant Production and Soil Sciences, University of Pretoria. Fresh plant material was sliced and hydro-distilled by using a clevenger-type apparatus with slight modifications (Evans 1989). Heat was provided by a heating-mantle equipped with a thermostat and the temperature was maintained at 90 °C. Two hundred grams of plant material mixed with 400 mL of distilled water was placed into a round bottomed flask and hydro-distilled for 2 hours. The distillate was collected as the essential oil band above the water. The essential oil obtained was stored in a refrigerator at 4 °C until used. A mixture of n-hexane and the distillate was prepared and the following concentrations were used: 0.107 mL/mL, 0.053 mL/mL and 0.027 mL/mL. The components of the essential oil were determined by Gas chromatography (GC) and Gas chromatography-linked mass spectrometry (GC-MS), (QP 20-10 Shimadzu GC-MS instrument).
Gas chromatography conditions
The column temperature was programmed to rise from 50 °C to 300 °C at 10 °C/min. The injector temperature was 250 °C. The total flow rate was 24 mL/min and the column flow rate was 1 mL/min.
Gas chromatography-linked mass spectrometry conditions
One μL of essential oil was analysed by using a GC-MS instrument equipped with a Supelco equity 1 column with a film thickness of 30 m x 0.25 pm. Ultra high purity helium was used as the carrier gas with an injector split ratio of 20:1. The ion source and interphase temperatures were 200 °C and 250 °C, respectively. The solvent cut time lasted 4 min and the detector gain was 0.70 kV. A Wiley 229 library search was conducted on major peaks of each sample in order to identify the components of the sample. The relative percentage of each compound was determined by area normalisation methods, whereby the area under the peak was calculated as (width at half height) x height (Houghton & Raman 1998).
The tick-climbing repellency bioassay used in this study was a modification of that described by Carroll (1998). Two glass rods of similar length were each fixed vertically and firmly on a polystyrene platform (L = 5 cm, W = 5 cm, H = 3.5 cm). A height of 21 cm of each glass-rod was exposed above its platform. The two platforms with inserted glass rods were fixed separately on the inside of a plastic container (L = 35 cm, W = 24 cm and H = 8 cm). Water was added to the container in such a way that it completely surrounded each of the platforms and almost reached the height of each of the platforms. One hundred pL of the test solution (n-hexane plus distillate of T. minuta) was placed on a test filter paper strip (Whatman No. 1), (2.5 cm x 5 cm). A control filter paper strip of the same kind and size was impregnated with n-hexane only. After evaporating the solvent by air-drying, the filter paper strips (test and control) were used to cover the top 5 cm of the respective glass-rods. Two additional neutral filter paper strips of the same size (2.5 cm x 1.5 cm) were each fixed below the test and control filter papers on the glass rods so that the adjacent edges of the filter papers met. Ten adults of H. rufipes of both sexes were released separately on the test and control platforms, and five replicates for each treatment (male and female) group were performed. The positions of ticks on the glass rods were recorded 1 hour after their release. Ticks that were found on the upper filter paper were considered not to be repelled. Those on the bottom neutral filter paper, on the naked part of the glass-rod, and on the platform were considered repelled. Ticks that moved into the water were dried and replaced. The repellent effect was calculated as percentage repellency, according to the formula:
Percentage repellency = 100 - [(Mean no. of ticks on the upper filter paper on test rods) / (mean no. of ticks on upper filter paper on control rods)] x 100. (Jantan & Zaki 1998)
Growth inhibition bioassay
In this bioassay, 10 μL of T. minuta essential oil was applied on a 1 cm x 1 cm filter paper (Whatman no. 1). The filter paper was introduced into a glass vial (height = 7.2 cm and diameter = 2.3 cm) containing 10 engorged nymphs held in a plastic net (25 mesh) to prevent direct contact with the essential oil. The control had untreated filter paper. The top of the glass vial was plugged with cotton wool (weight 0.99 g), held tight in tissue paper (3 cm x 3 cm) allowing the air in the test glass vial to be saturated with volatiles from the essential oil. The bioassay was replicated five times in the test and control treatments. Glass vials containing ticks were carefully kept in chambers at 75 ± 5% relative humidity, 25 ± 1 °C and a natural day-night regime. Test and control vials were kept in separate chambers, but laboratory conditions for both groups were the same. The number of ticks that completely moulted 25 days post-treatment was counted and percentage inhibition calculated with the formula:
Percentage inhibition = 100 x [(1 - percentage moult in treated group) ÷ (percentage moult in control group)]. (Lok, Pollack & Donnelly 1987)
Data analysis Repellency bioassay
Probit analysis (EPA 2006) was used to determine the effective concentration needed to repel 50% (EC50) of ticks as well as the Confidence Interval (CI) of the mean number of ticks repelled by the plant extract. Each replication was considered independently. Confidence intervals (95%) of EC50 were used to determine the difference in the response between male and female ticks (Lerdthusnee et al. 2003). Data were normalised by transformation into the arc sin square root of the proportion of ticks repelled or inhibited from moulting prior to subjecting it to one-way independent ANOVA (analysis of variances), (Hammer, Harper & Ryan 2001). The repellent responses of male and female ticks for each concentration were pooled together for ANOVA, because no significant differences were found between male and female ticks at all concentrations for T. minuta essential oil; however, the mean (± s.e.) of untransformed data are reported.
Growth inhibition bioassay
The number of nymphs that moulted completely to adults was counted and data were presented as percentage inhibition of moulting. The Student's t-test was used to determine significance of the differences (P < 0.05) between the treatments.
This study was approved by the Animal Ethics Committee, University of Limpopo, MEDUNSA Campus. Rabbits used in the study were treated humanely.
The yield of the essential oil of T. minuta obtained, following distillation, was 1 mL per 200 g of fresh plant material. The GC-MS analysis of the distillate of the aerial parts of T. minuta revealed that the oil is rich in terpenes (Table 1). The major constituents of T. minuta essential oil were cis-ocimene (28.50%), beta-ocimene (16.83%) and 3-methyl-2-(2-methyl-2-butenyl)-furan (11.94%). In the tick-climbing repellency bioassay, H. rufipes showed a significant (P < 0.05) dose repellent response in the climbing repellency bioassay (Table 2). Probit analysis indicated a repellent EC50 of T. minuta essential oil for male ticks to be 0.07 mL/mL and 0.07 mL/mL for female ticks. With a density of ± 0.87 mg/mL (Azafran 2004), this equates to an EC50 of ± 0.06 mg/mL. The repellent responses between male and female ticks did not differ significantly (Table 3). Furthermore, the essential oil of T. minuta delayed moulting in 60% (s.e. ± 4.7) of nymphs after 25 days, compared to the control group.
The essential oil of T. minuta used in this study was rich in terpenes based on GC and GC-MS analysis. Chemical analysis carried out on different species of Tagetes grown in Northern Italy indicated that dihydrotagetone, tagetones, ocimenones and piperitone occurred in Tagetes erecta, T. minuta, Tagetes patula and Tagetes tenuifolia (Marotti et al. 2004). These compounds were also present in the essential oil of T. minuta evaluated in this study.
The results obtained in this study indicate that the essential oil of T. minuta has tick repellent and growth inhibitory properties. Tick repellency by the essential oil of T. minuta, corroborates studies by Lwande et al. (1999) who further showed that this was because of one of its constituents, betaocimene. Even though it is important to evaluate individual compounds in suitable bioassays for repellency (Lwande et al. 1999), whole oil, such as the one used in this study, may cause increased bioactivity compared to individual compounds because of synergistic effects. Ticks have highly efficient sensory organs. The tick's sensory organ, the Haller's organ, is situated on the dorsal surface of each foreleg and it has both olfactory and gustatory chemosensilla (Sonenshine 1991). Olfactory chemoreceptors or sensilla perceive volatiles, whilst gustatory chemoreceptors perceive stimuli on contact (McMahon, Kröber & Guerin 2003).
Despite the necessity to explore plant based repellents as tick control agents, there is still a future need to improve on the longevity of effective, yet extremely volatile repellents in order to compete with registered compounds. Several studies deal with the improvement of formulations of plant oils to increase their longevity through the development of nano-emulsions, improved formulations and fixatives (Maia & Moore 2011). Kaaya and Saxena (1998) used petroleum jelly as a carrier for plant extract during an in vivo study. A further approach that could be relevant in the sustainable management of ticks is through the disruption of their life cycle by targeting engorged immature stages. This may result in the reduction of tick infestations to low and controllable levels, hence reducing the tick population during favourable climatic conditions. During this study, moulting of engorged nymphs of H. rufipes was significantly (P < 0.05) delayed by 60%. This could be attributed to tagetone, one of the identified constituents of T. minuta used in this study, possessing growth inhibitory properties (Jacobson 1983). These results are in agreement with findings of another study; the essential oil of a variety of T. minuta (genotype TM-1) deterred oviposition in Tribolium castaneum Herbst (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae) by 81% and suppressed its egg hatchability by 91% when applied at a dosage of 70 000 ppm on filter paper (Alok et al. 2005). The bioactive compound(s) are very likely to be of a volatile nature as no direct contact was established between ticks and the extracts. The rate at which the volatiles diffuse from the glass vials could not be determined, but the delay in moulting indicates that the bioactive constituents of T. minuta should be very effective to produce such results with a single dose. Other herbal products that contain essential oils such as citronella oil or Chrysanthemum spp. (containing pyrethrum), are available as commercial arthropod repellents (Fradin & Day 2002).
The use of botanicals for the control of ticks is compatible with traditional practices in Africa and Asia, where most resource-poor farmers use plant materials to treat endoparasites and ectoparasites of livestock (Lans & Brown 1998; Madge 1998). Traditional knowledge about the use of these plants is transferred through successive generations, especially in rural communities. Knowledge about the use of individual plant species, however, varies between localities in Africa, and scientific validation of their uses may increase the range of plants available for tick control. This may reduce the burden substantially on plant species that are at risk of extinction.
The results obtained in this study suggest that T. minuta is a potential source of tick control agents. Although T. minuta is a common weed in rural areas, it is unlikely that high enough concentrations of the volatile oils would be reached to affect ticks when animals are housed closely together with certain plants scattered on the ground. The extracted essential oil of T. minuta, however, may be of use in the integrated control of H. rufipes or other insects.
The National Research Foundation, South Africa, provided funding for the project. MEDUNSA (now merged with the University of Limpopo) and the University of Pretoria provided laboratory equipment. Colleagues in the Department of Biology, University of Limpopo, and Dr D. Katerere and Dr P. Soundy from the University of Pretoria made valuable contributions.
The authors declare that they have no financial or personal relationship(s) which may have inappropriately influenced them in writing this paper.
S.R.M. (University of South Africa) and J.N.E. (University of Pretoria) were the project leaders and made conceptual contributions and edited the final manuscripts, F.N. (Cape Peninsula University of Technology) made conceptual contributions, performed the experiments and wrote the first draft of the manuscript.
Abdel-Shafy, S. & Zayeb, A.A., 2002, 'In vitro acaricidal effect of plant extract of neem seed oil (Azadirachta indica) on egg, immature and adult stages of Hyalomma anatolicaum excavatum (Ixodidoidea; Ixodidae)', Veterinary Parasitology 106, 89-96. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0304-4017(02)00023-7. [ Links ]
Alok, K., Veena, P., Bhasney, S., Tripathi, A.K. & Sushil, K., 2005, 'Potential toxicity of new genotypes of Tagetes (Astereaceae) species against stored grain insect pest', International Journal of Tropical Insect Science 25, 122-128. [ Links ]
Azafran, 2004, Tagetes oil, viewed 02 August 2011, from http://www.azafrangroup.com/msds/TAGETES%20OIL%20MSDS.pdf [ Links ]
Bhattacarya, B., Sarkar, S.K. & Mukherjee, N., 2003, 'Organochloride pesticide residues in sediments of a tropical mangrove estuary, India; implications for monitoring', Environment International 1052, 1-6. [ Links ]
Carroll, J.F., 1998, 'Kairomonal activity of White-tailed deer metatarsal gland substances: A more sensitive behavioral bioassay using Ixodes scapularis (Acari: Ixodidae)', Journal of Medical Entomology 35, 90-93. PMid:9542351 [ Links ]
EPA (Environmental Protection Agency), 2006, Ecological Exposure Division. Statistical analysis for biological methods. Probit analysis, viewed 06 May 2010, from http://www.epa.gov/nerleerd/stat2.htm [ Links ]
Evans, W.C., 1989, Trease and Evans' Pharmacognosy, 13th edn., Baillêrre Tindall, London. [ Links ]
Fradin, M.S. & Day, J.F., 2002, 'Comparative efficacy of insect repellents against mosquito bites', New England Journal of Medicine 347, 13-18. http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa011699, PMid:12097535 [ Links ]
Gray, J.S. & De Vos, A.J., 1981, 'Studies on a bovine Babesia transmitted by Hyalomma marginatum rufipes', Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research 48, 215-223. PMid:7345388 [ Links ]
Hammer, 0., Harper, D.A.T. & Ryan, P.D., 2001, PAST: Paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis, Palaeontologia Electronic (1), viewed 24 May 2004, from http://palaeo-electronica.org/2001_1/past/issue1_01.htm [ Links ]
Jacobson, M., 1983, Plants: The potentials for extracting protein, medicines, and other useful chemicals - Workshop proceedings Washington D.C., US. Congress, Office of Technology Assessment: OTA -F-23, pp 138-146. [ Links ]
Jantan, I. & Zaki, M.Z., 1998, 'Development of environment-friendly insect repellents from the leaf oils of selected Malaysian plants', ASEAN Review of Biodiversity and Environmental Conservation (ARBEC), 1-7. [ Links ]
Kaaya, G.P. & Saxena, R.C., 1998, 'Evaluation of neem products for the control of the African ticks Rhipicephalus appendiculatus, Amblyomma variegatum and Boophilus decoloratus' ICIPE Annual Scientific Report 1995-1997, pp 165-167. [ Links ]
Kivaria, F.M., 2006, 'Estimated direct economic costs associated with tick-borne diseases on cattle in Tanzania', Tropical Animal Health and Production 38, 291299. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11250-006-4181-2, PMid:17137131 [ Links ]
Lans, C. & Brown, G., 1998, 'Ethnoveterinary medicines used for ruminants in Trinidad and Tobago', Preventive Veterinary Medicine 35, 149-163. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0167-5877(98)00066-X [ Links ]
Li, A.Y., Davey, R.B., Miller, R.J. & George, J.E., 2003, 'Resistance to Coumaphos and Diazinon in Boophilus microplus (Acari: Ixodidae) and Evidence for the Involvement of an Oxidative Detoxication Mechanism', Journal of Medical Entomology 40, 482490. http://dx.doi.org/10.1603/0022-2585-40A482, PMid:14680115 [ Links ]
Lerdthusnee, K., Khlaimanee, N., Monkanna, T., Mungviriya, S., Leepitakrat, W., Debboun, M. et al., 2003, 'Development of an In Vitro Method for the Evaluation of Candidate Repellents Against Leptotrombidium (Acari: Trombiculidae) Chiggers', Journal of Medical Entomology 40, 64-67. http://dx.doi.org/10.1603/0022-2585-40.1.64, PMid:12597654 [ Links ]
Lok, J.B., Pollack, R.J. & Donnelly, J.J., 1987, 'Studies on the Growth-Regulating Effects of Ivermectin on Larval Onchocerca lienaris In Vitro' Journal of Parasitology 73, 80-84. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/3282347, PMid:3572669 [ Links ]
Lwande, W., Ndakala, A.J., Hassanali, A., Moreka, L., Nyandat, E., Ndungu, M. et al., 1999, 'Gynandropsis gynandra essential oil and its constituents as tick (Rhipicephalus appendiculatus) repellents', Phytochemistry 50, 401-405. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0031-9422(98)00507-X [ Links ]
Maia, M.F. & Moore, S.J., 2011, 'Plant-based insect repellents: a review of their efficacy, development and testing', Malaria Journal 10 (Suppl 1), S11. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1475-2875-10-S1-S11, PMid:21411012 [ Links ]
Magano, S.R., Els, D.A. & Chown, S.L., 2000, 'Feeding patterns of immature stages of Hyalomma truncatum and Hyalomma marginatum rufipes on different hosts', Experimental and Applied Acarology 24, 301-313. http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/A:1006457325097 [ Links ]
Marotti, M., Piccaglia, R., Biavati, B. & Marotti, I., 2004, 'Characterization and yield evaluation of essential oils from different Tagetes species', Journal of Essential oil Research, viewed 10 August 2010, from http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa4091/is_200409/ai_n9432415 [ Links ]
McCosker, P.J., 1979, Global aspects of the management and control of ticks of veterinary importance. Recent Advances in Acarology, Academic Press, New York, NY. [ Links ]
McMahon, C., Króber, T. & Guerin, P.M., 2003, 'In vitro assays for repellents and deterrents for ticks: differing effects of products when tested with attractant or arrestment stimuli', Medical and Veterinary Entomology 17, 370-378. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2915.2003.00453.x, PMid:14651650 [ Links ]
Moyo, B., Masika, P.J., Dube, S. & Maphosa, V., 2009, 'An in-vivo study of the efficacy and safety of ethno-veterinary remedies used to control cattle ticks by rural farmers in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa', Tropical Animal Health and Production 41, 1569-1576. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11250-008-9216-4, PMid:18704741 [ Links ]
Mwangi, E.N., Hassanali, A., Essuman, S., Nyadat, E., Moreka, L. & Kimondo, M., 1995, 'Repellent and acaricidal properties of Ocimum suave against Rhipicephalus appendiculatus ticks', Experimental and Applied Acarology 19, 11-18. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00051933 [ Links ]
Sonenshine, D.E., 1991, Biology of ticks: Volume 1, Oxford University Press, New York. [ Links ]
Walker, A.R., Bouattour, A., Camicas, J-L., Estrada-Peña, A., Horak, I.G., Latif, A.A. et al., 2003, Ticks of domestic animals in Africa: A guide to identification of species, Bioscience Reports, Atalanta. [ Links ]
Wanzala, W., 2009, 'Ethnobotanicals for management of the brown ear tick Rhipicephalus appendiculatus in western Kenya', PhD thesis, Laboratory of Entomology, Wageningen University, Netherlands. [ Links ]
PO Box 652, Cape Town 8000, South Africa
Received: 28 June 2011
Accepted: 09 Nov. 2011
Published: 30 Mar. 2012