In die Skriflig
On-line version ISSN 1018-6441
VERHEYDEN, Joseph. Matthew's building blocks: Mark and Q - A critical look at a recent monograph. In Skriflig (Online) [online]. 2015, vol.49, n.1, pp. 1-10. ISSN 1018-6441. http://dx.doi.org/10.4102/IDS.V49I1.1988.
This article offers a critical analysis of some of the principal arguments put forward in a recent monograph by J.A. Doole in defence of the thesis that Matthew, whilst being familiar with Mark and Q, had a clear preference for the former in structuring his composition. Doole argues that Matthew used Q only in such a way that it never threatened to disrupt the dominance of Mark, used up Q 'as quick as possible', and was more at ease in Mark which he used both de visu and from memory. Against these positions, it is shown that Q played a more prominent roll all throughout Matthew's gospel than Doole assumes it did and that the 'de visu / from memory' dichotomy does not match the evidence.