Abstract

KRUUSE, Helen  and  MWAMBENE, Lea. Recognising form through function in the context of integrating the bride requirement in customary marriages in South Africa. Afr. hum. rights law j. [online]. 2023, vol.23, n.2, pp.354-385. ISSN 1996-2096.  http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1996-2096/2023/v23n2a6.

In previous scholarship we argued how the state and courts have tended to favour a formal or definitional approach to customary marriages in South Africa, leaving vulnerable parties, particularly women, not adequately protected. In this article we focus on a new approach emerging from the courts, particularly relating to the integration of the bride as a requirement for the validity of a customary marriage. While we affirm the courts' emerging approach regarding integration, we take issue with the language used by the courts, particularly that relating to the word 'waiver'. In considering the recent South African Supreme Court of Appeal decisions on integration, and the High Court decisions that have followed, we believe the courts are in fact not waiving the requirement, but recognising that the requirement of integration may be met in another way. In considering these cases, although the court does not explicitly rely on Ramose's 'social acceptance' thesis as to the validity of law, we believe that adopting this approach will do much to assuage concerns about courts ignoring custom. More importantly, Ramose's 'social acceptance' theory gives credit to living customary law as a legal system which, as widely observed, promotes the very values on which the Constitution is founded. We also believe that Ramose's approach is a much more balanced approach in this context than a typically Western approach that promotes certainty over the protection of vulnerable parties, and represents the very evolving nature of living customary marriage laws and practices.

Keywords : customary marriage; integration of the bride; waiver; flexibility; evolution; Ramose; language; acceptance theory.

        · text in English     · English ( pdf )